Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
Select Page

Philadelphia Insurance Companies Review & Complaints: Auto Insurance

Philadelphia Insurance Companies' A.M. Best rating is A++ and A+ with the Better Business Bureau. Follow this Philadelphia Insurance Companies review for more regarding their commercial insurance policies, Philadelphia Insurance Companies subsidiaries, and where you can file Philadelphia Insurance Companies claims.

FREE Insurance Comparison

Compare quotes from the top insurance companies and save!

Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Eric Stauffer is a former insurance agent and banker turned consumer advocate. His priority is to help educate individuals and families about the different types of insurance they need, and assist them in finding the best...

Full Bio →

Written by

UPDATED: Sep 24, 2020

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We partner with top insurance providers. This doesn't influence our content. Our opinions are our own.

Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by insurance experts.

Philadelphia Insurance Companies
Financial Strength

The Highlights

  • The beginnings of Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY) date back to 1962.
  • The company mainly writes policies for sports and fitness clubs, non-profit organizations, and other specialty markets.
  • Currently, the only personal lines insurance available from PHLY is Antique/Collector Car insurance.

With roots going back to the early ’60s in its namesake city, Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY) is a homegrown insurer now serving the entire country. They mainly offer specialty products with a focus on commercial lines.

We understand that finding the best auto insurance for Pennsylvania can be a difficult task. This is why we will go through Philadelphia Insurance Companies step-by-step in our Philadelphia life and health insurance review.

How affordable are Philadelphia Insurance Companies and other insurers? Find out by typing your ZIP code into our helpful and FREE tool above to find reasonable rates in your area.

PHLY Car Insurance Rates

The beginnings of Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY) can be traced back to an insurance agency formed by James J. Maguire, Sr. in 1962. After landing a contract with Chevrolet, his company spent the ’70s expanding operations into other states. Maguire formed a holding company in 1980, under which he then opened Philadelphia Insurance Companies in 1987.

To this day, PHLY specializes in serving two main niche markets: sports and fitness clubs and non-profit organizations. They mainly write commercial package policies for these and other specialty markets. The following PHLY commercial explains how they cater to niche markets, including non-profit organizations.

Currently, the only personal lines insurance available from PHLY is Antique/Collector Car insurance, although they do write flood insurance through the National Flood Insurance Program. This video goes into detail about their work with the National Flood Insurance Program, including tips on how to protect your property from flooding.


So, how affordable is Philadelphia Insurance Companies, and what are their rates? It depends on a variety of factors, including your location. Let’s read on to find out more.

What is PHLY’s availability by state?

PHLY maintains headquarters in its original city, but the company has offices in 50 locations across the country. They operate today as part of Tokio Marine Group, a large international insurance group.

Before we discuss what coverages are offered by PHLY, feel free to find some quotes from a few of the best insurance companies below.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

PHLY Car Insurance Coverages Offered

PHLY offers a wide variety of commercial package policies for specialty markets, as well as specialty liability and a handful of other products. They also offer multiple commercial coverage options for specialty markets, including:

  • Education
  • Entertainment and Recreation
  • Habitational
  • Health and Fitness
  • Industry Services
  • Non-profit and Human Services
  • Outdoor Products
  • Public Services
  • Real Estate
  • Special Events
  • Sports

As you can see, PHLY services a wide array of industries. Additionally, Philadelphia Insurance Companies offers many bundling options.

What are PHLY’s bundling options?

Each package policy can be customized with endorsements and products that include commercial auto insurance business coverage and specialized liability. You might be asking, “Does Philadelphia Insurance Companies offer car insurance?” They do, but there is a catch.

There is a selection of other products listed on the PHLY website, including Antique and Collector Car coverage that is available both as a personal policy and commercial policy. These products are written in partnership with Grundy, a specialty insurer that mainly writes classic car coverage.

PHLY also writes the aforementioned flood insurance for personal and commercial needs and group participant accident insurance. This can be purchased for sporting events, camps, volunteer events, and more.

You may be wondering, “Can I buy Philadelphia Insurance Companies coverage online?” Due to the nature of their business, they do not offer rates on their website, nor is there an online quoting option. This makes sense, as commercial insurance is complex and a large number of factors can figure into the final rate. Unfortunately, it renders the question “How much are policies on average for Philadelphia Insurance Companies?” difficult to answer with any precision. Thankfully, PHLY offers multiple discounts.

What are discounts offered by PHLY?

PHLY has partnered with Training for Intervention ProcedureS (TIPS) in the hopes of providing cheap training solutions for those who hold liquor liability policies with PHLY. These seminars help to:

  • Spot underage drinkers and prevent sales to minors.
  • Recognize signs of intoxication.
  • Effectively intervene to prevent potential problem situations.
  • Handle refusal situations with greater confidence.

This training ultimately helps to reduce liability and includes the following benefits:

  • Reducing exposure to alcohol liability lawsuits.
  • Addressing alcohol-related issues specific to your environment.
  • Reducing penalties for alcohol violations.
  • Improving customer service and professionalism.

It’s even better for policyholders because, in addition to discounts, PHLY also offers a number of programs.

What programs are available from PHLY?

PHLY offers many great programs to its policyholders. They have abuse prevention training via their PHLY Risk Management Services department for human services providers. This is to educate those in the field on appropriate interactions between human service providers and their clients.

They also partner with The ALICE Training Institute to give seminars on responding to a violent intruder. Here is a promo ad for ALICE that illustrates the importance of holding such seminars.

ALICE Training Institute exists to educate individuals on how to properly respond to an armed shooter instance. Let’s take a look at a table showing the topics covered in this program.

ALICE Violent Intruder Training Institute Seminar Topics
ALICE Seminar Component
Early warning signs of potential violent persons
Case histories and lessons learned
Can infrastructure security measures keep us safe?
Effective barricading & evacuation strategies
Liability concerns of following outdated plans & policies
Get Your Rates Quote Now

In addition to active shooters, they also have an abuse prevention system in place. This is operated by sexual abuse attorneys and provides online resources that have been proven to reduce the risk of child abuse in children’s programs.

Here is a video on the Child Abuse Safety System that provides some statistics, as well as goals for the program.


Free Car Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Canceling your PHLY Car Insurance Policy

Is there a cancellation fee?

No cancellation fee is listed, but this would be well worth inquiring about with your insurance agent.

Is there a refund?

The company policy is to issue a refund within 30 days via a mailed check. According to customer reviews from the Better Business Bureau, however, PHLY can sometimes provide misinformation in regards to refund amounts or whether or not a refund will even be received in the first place.

How do you cancel?

According to PHLY’s website, a policyholder may cancel their policy by emailing with their name, policy number, and date of cancellation.

When can I cancel?

Philadelphia Insurance Companies’ website does not list any particular time period during which a policyholder can cancel their policy. This lack of information makes it imperative that you inquire with your agent.

How to Make a PHLY Car Insurance Claim

“How can I contact Philadelphia Insurance Companies?” There is a variety of options for those seeking PHLY’s contact info. Claims can be reported with an online form that is offered for several different lines of business. There is also an email address through which claims can be submitted.

Toll-free phone numbers are available to make claims through Philadelphia Insurance Companies, one for during business hours and another for use after hours. The Philadelphia Insurance Company’s phone number is 1-804-290-7940. Their 24/7 catastrophe line can be reached at 1-800-765-9749. A mailing address for claims is also listed on the site.

Auto glass claims are handled by HSG, a Philadelphia-based auto glass repair service. There is a different toll-free number that should be used for this type of claim.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

PHLY: Car Insurance Ratings

“How does Philadelphia Insurance Companies compare to other companies? Is Philadelphia Insurance Companies a reliable company?”

Philadelphia Insurance Companies has an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (BBB), with a total of 16 complaints on file in the past three years. Eight of those were closed in the past twelve months.

Philadelphia Insurance Companies’ ratings on the customer side are lackluster. There are seven reviews on Yelp, and of these, the only positive review appears to be from a professional reviewer and not a true client of the company. The remainder of the reviews are one-star and focus on poor customer service and claims handling.

Philadelphia Insurance Companies Review: The Bottom Line

If you are in the market for specialty commercial insurance products, PHLY might be worth a deeper look. Due to the general lack of information available on the company, we are unable to provide a solid recommendation based on the limited information we were able to obtain.

Now that you’ve finished our Philadelphia Insurance Companies review, feel free to use our helpful tool below to find reasonable rates in Philadelphia by typing in your ZIP code.

Frequently Asked Questions: Philadelphia Insurance Companies Review

#1 – Does Philadelphia Insurance Companies offer employee benefits?

Yes, they offer investment incentives, medical benefits, volunteer benefits, paid vacation, and more. These can be accessed via the Philadelphia Insurance agent login.

#2 – How do I change my address on Philadelphia Insurance Companies policy?

Their website does not list a specific way to change your address, but you can log in to your MyPHLY account if you’re a policyholder or call them at 1-877-438-7459 to inquire.

#3 – What is PHLY fitness insurance?

This is a subsection of PHLY that is tailored to the fitness industry. PHLY proudly states that 90 percent of its employees use their onsite gym and over 10 percent of its employees annually compete in various athletic competitions.

#4 – Where can I find Philadelphia insurance company reviews?

Better Business Bureau and A.M. Best are two excellent options when it comes to company reviews. If you want former or current employee reviews, is a helpful resource.

#5 – How do I file a Philadelphia Insurance Companies payment?

You can pay online, call 1-877-438-7459, or pay by mail to the following address:

Philadelphia Insurance Companies  P.O. Box 70251  Philadelphia, PA 19176-0251.

You can also send payments overnight to:

Philadelphia Insurance Companies   Attn: Cash Department  One Bala Plaza, Suite 100  Bala Cynwyd, PA 19004-0950.

#6 – What is Philadelphia Insurance Companies’ number of employees?

As of 2020, Philadelphia Insurance Companies employs 1,600 people in 50 offices across the country.

#7 – Is Philadelphia Insurance Companies’ pay online option still available?

Yes, you can pay your bills online as long as you have a User ID and Password to access their website. You can either log in to your MyPHLY account or create an account, then select Online Bill Pay in the left-hand menu. They also accept electronic checks from your checking or savings account.

[su_spoiler title=”References:” icon=”caret-square” style=”fancy” open=”yes”]



Review Date
Philadelphia Insurance Companies
Author Rating

About Eric Stauffer

Author: Eric StaufferI am a former insurance agent and banker turned consumer advocate. My priority is to help educate individuals and families about the different types of insurance they need, and assist them in finding the best place to get it.


  1. August 5, 2019.

    Philadelphia Insurance Co. Just denied my liability injury claim so now I’m left with no choice but to have the (California Department of Insurance) review this matter!!

  2. Philadelphia insurance companies are scam artists.. They will take your money but if you hit someone they will not pay and you will get sued.

    If you want real insurance find another company.

  3. All of us with complaints should all get together and do a class action lawsuit against this company call Philadelphia

    I sure they are scamming people out auto insurance renters insurance and life insurance

    Philadelphia insurance are scamming people

  4. No don’t do it. Go somewhere else, they are worsted insurance company out there.

  5. We’ve been a liability client of Philadelphia for 8 years, never missed a payment, never made a claim until this year when a client filed a fraudulent lawsuit against us. The lawyers handling the suit are doing a good job of fighting the suit, but in the meantime, Philadelphia has cancelled us…for one lawsuit filed by an aggrieved client, for which we provably had no blame or responsibility. The company would not even give us an extension to find affordable liability insurance. Our agent says this has happened a few times, which leads me to believe that Philadelphia has no intention of standing behind its loyal policyholders in the event of a claim or problem. That should definitely be a factor when deciding whether this is a company with which you want to do business.

  6. I was sideswiped by one of Philadelphia’s commercial insured’s and even with evidence the accident was on their insured, they completely ignored the claim. I even mailed DVD’s of the police body and dash cams overnight to the adjuster and his supervisor, it seemed they didn’t accept the packages from what UPS has told me and returned them to the sender. I did the homework for these guys and they still denied the claim. So facts and evidence are pushed to the side in order to not take liability for their customers. If this is how a small claim is handled, I couldn’t imagine being a customer with a larger claim.

  7. I’m looking at jumping ship on my existing health insurance company and thinking about signing up with Philadelphia American Health Insurance. Is it a good health insurance company in regards to benefits and claims?
    What types of consumer reviews are they getting?

  8. How good is Philadelphia health Insurance?

  9. Worst insurance company I have delt with. Philadelphia Insurance company insures Spinx Convenience stores in South Carolina. I own a business in the State as well. I purchased gas at the Spinx in [Redacted] in May for our motor home. We spent 75.00. We had just drove an hour from our house to Landrum and our motor home drove great!!! It was out 1st out of town trip. We were headed to Cowpen battlefield in Chesney. After we gased up at Spinx…..It was all down hill from Spinx. The motor home started sputtering cutting off. It was a scary horrible experience and the most expensive repair I have ever had ALL BECAUSE SPINX HAS GAS WITH WATER IN IT!!!! We were locked in a National park with a park ranger mot happy he had to stay late because of our camper breaking down. Spinx has refused to compensate us for all the damage their gasdid to our Motor home!!! A bill for 900.00 and a bill for 1,997.00 bill as well. The people a Spinx [Redacted] is professional and courteous. His insurance company on the other hand not so much. I even have the proof that the gas had water in it. The mechanic saved me a sample for Spinx. It had like 5 or 10% water in the gas. [Redacted] AT PHILADELPHIA INS. Said my claim was denied because no one else complained….really. most people would have just thought it was just there car…. NO ITS SPINX GAS!!!! I WILL NEVER PUT MY PROPERTY IN JEOPARDY OF BEING DESTROYED BY THEIR GAS EVER AGAIN!!!!

  10. is Philadelphia ins. a good life ins. company Mr. Eric. Yhanks for the help Mr. Covington

    • Hi Jesse,

      I believe that Philadelphia Insurance Co. is a good company. I am personally impressed with the way their founder built the company, and I recommend looking at them for anyone that is considering insurance that they specialize in.

      Eric Stauffer

    • No. They don’t pay claims and they are very rude and unprofessional to deal with. I have personally dealt with them. Don’t walk, run!


Leave a Rating

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *