Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
Select Page

Allstate Home Insurance Review & Complaints: Home Insurance

The average Allstate home insurance rates are $377.75/mo. Allstate is the number two insurance provider in the nation and makes an effort to give back to the community, and homeowners are easily covered with affordable rates that are slightly below competitors.

FREE Insurance Comparison

Compare quotes from the top insurance companies and save!

Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Eric Stauffer is a former insurance agent and banker turned consumer advocate. His priority is to help educate individuals and families about the different types of insurance they need, and assist them in finding the best...

Full Bio →

Written by

UPDATED: Sep 18, 2020

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We partner with top insurance providers. This doesn't influence our content. Our opinions are our own.

Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by insurance experts.

Allstate Insurance OverviewDetails
Year Founded1931
Current ExecutivesPresident & CEO - Tom Wilson
Number of Employees10,000 Agency Owners &
24,000+ Licensed Sales Professionals
Total Sales/Assets$112.2 billion (2018)
HQ Address2775 Sanders Road,
Northbrook, IL, 60062
Phone Number1-847-402-5000
Company Websitewww.allstate.com
Premiums Written8,262,445
Loss Ratio65.55%
Best ForDiscounts, first time homebuyers,
homesharing hosts, young parents,
cheap rates
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Your home and the belongings within that home are often the most important investments in your life. That is not to say a person is made-up of the things they own, but in the real world, a home is a significant financial investment not just in the present for safety and shelter but also your future, both in living conditions and financial well-being.

As with any investment, you need to be prepared for unexpected loss or damage by safeguarding that investment with an insurance policy that is affordable and fits your needs as a homeowner.  The good hands of Allstate, now the number two insurance provider in the nation with its wide range insurance policies, have got you covered on this front.

The people who live in your home are not seen as a tangible investment, but they are just as important to you. You have invested your time, love, and appreciation in them you want to protect them. Allstate understands the importance of safeguarding your family by providing homeowners insurance as well as multiple additional coverage options to protect those you hold most dear.

When it comes to home and the many other types of insurance you may need, Allstate has more than enough options. They have been covering America for over 80 years with an ever-changing business model placing consumer needs front and center. They offer just about any insurance you could possibly need. And with that wide list of insurance lines comes a series of bundling discounts as well as the convenience of keeping all of your insurance under the same roof.

From their start as a mail-order insurance provider that transitioned into a more personal agent-based business model and now is pivoting again taking full advantage of online capabilities, they have shown an ability to adapt to the needs of the consumer in an ever-changing market. Their home insurance policies offer coverage for a variety of living situations including standard homeowners, condos, renters, and landlords, and every Allstate agent is dedicated to working with you to find the right policy to fit your home and life plan.

How can you tell if Allstate is right for you?  We can help. We’ve provided a detailed run-down of Allstate as the nation’s number two insurance provider. Below you will find our full review of Allstate’s credit ratings and financial stability, market share data, customer reviews, and the ease/difficulty of their claims process. The information will help you better understand Allstate as a company but more importantly if their policies will meet your home insurance needs.

If you’d like to start comparing rates now, try out our free online quote option above. Get a head start on planning for the safety and well-being of your financial investment of today and tomorrow.

Allstate Ratings

As a top ten ranked insurance provider, it may be easier to just assume that, as their slogan appropriately implies, you will be in good hands if you take out a home insurance policy with Allstate. However, the easy way hardly ever affords you the trust and security you need when it comes to safeguarding your home investment. Rankings are all good and well to give you a general idea of how a company performs, but a more in-depth look provides the good faith that you are not just in good hands, but the right hands to meet your needs as a homeowner. What good is the most affordable policy that meets your needs as a homeowner if the customer service fails to match those same standards making the entire claims process a nightmare?

Since we are never ones to assume when it comes to securing one of your biggest investments not just for today but for the future as well, we have taken the liberty to check further into Allstate’s background diving deep into their credit rankings, industry reports, and customer satisfaction reviews. All things considered, Allstate may be a safe-bet as the number two home insurance provider for multiple perils, but wouldn’t you rather hedge your bets with some insider information making it a true sure thing when it comes to a payout on your investment.

The chart below lists a quick overview, or scorecard if you will, showing just how Allstate stacks up as a fiscally responsible company that services its policyholders well.

Ratings AgencyRating
A.M. BestA+
Better Business BureauA+
Moody's RatingAa3
S&P RatingAA-
NAIC Complaint Index0.81
Fitch RatingA+
J.D. Power3/5-3/5
Get Your Rates Quote Now

If we are going by grade school rules, then Allstate appears to have an honor roll report card, and that assumption is not too far off. The snapshot above attests that Allstate has an above-average credit ranking with a very stable outlook of continued growth in the future. It also suggests that their customer service is a little more than adequate since they remain below the national average of measured complaints in the insurance industry.

At this point, you may have started asking yourself the big three questions. What are these watchdog agencies? How do they rate each company? And more importantly, why do their opinions matter? When it comes to picking the right homeowners policy that meets your needs, you need to make sure that your insurance provider can back you up financially in the here and now but also in the years to come. You also want to make sure that they’re capable of servicing your claims in the customer service department.

We have gone ahead and answered those big 3 below with a detailed rundown of each of these rating agencies to give a better understanding of how Allstate operates as a company in the past, present, and future.

A.M. Best

Operating as a financial watchdog for the insurance industry since 1899, A.M. Best has reviewed over 100 years of insurance policy work bringing with them a high measure of clout, a wealth of experience, and industry knowledge. A.M. Best remains one of the major credit ranking agencies that round out the majority of opinions and facts for the financial solvency of insurance providers; out of the other credit ranking agencies, A.M. Best earns our top of the list spot for focusing solely on the insurance industry.

Their ranking system measures not just the quantity but also the quality of the company as a financial investment with the bonus of projecting the potential future outlook of operating performance as well. Below is a detailed chart of each letter grade on their scale what they mean for any given insurance provider.

AM Best Rating Guide

A.M. Best awarded Allstate with top marks as they received an A++ rating. The review from Best states the assertion that Allstate is both financially stable now and poised for significant growth. They are in a superior, to use the ratings agency’s lingo, position as an insurance provider from the credit angle and even received extra + marks to reflect recent change and growth. Allstate is stable and experiencing significant growth in the financial sector which means they are a safe investment for your future.

Better Business Bureau

Think of the Better Business Bureau (BBB) as the nation’s complaint department. They field complaints on both a national and local level for any companies operating in the United States; BBB assigns ratings from A+ (highest) to F (lowest). They process these reviews to provide accountability, higher working standards, and positive feedback by giving the consumer a voice. And here we thought yelp was such a novel idea to provide feedback and hold restaurants to a higher standard when the BBB has been at it even longer.

The BBB’s rating system takes a systematic approach to measuring the number of complaints a business receives as well as a company’s efficiency in responding to those complaints. The ultimate goal is to provide everyday consumers with an inside look into how their local businesses operate, so these very same consumers can conduct transactions with a business they can trust.

A positive rating with the BBB goes a long way in explaining how a company operates daily with actual consumers. If an affordable policy fits your needs as a homeowner, but you can not easily file your claim, then what good are the savings or the policy for that matter? Customer service is just as important in our minds as the policy itself. They kind of go hand-in-hand, and the BBB is here to help consumers make more educated purchasing decisions.

Allstate received an A+ rating from the BBB. It is reassuring to know that not only will your policy be affordable while providing all the necessary coverage but the claims and any customer issues will be handled appropriately in a timely fashion as well.

Moody’s

Moody’s is the first of the big three credit rating agencies we will take a look at in determining the financial stability of Allstate. In operation since 1909, Moody’s provides informative surveys, reviews, and ratings that give an outlook on the fiscal solvency of corporations across the globe. Opinions and subsequent ratings are based on facts, market trends, and an even-handed measure of experience with the financial prospects of any given company.

Moody’s conducts a regular review process that takes place yearly and sometimes monthly providing updates on top corporations’ financial integrity or lack thereof.

Considering your home or in the least your investment in your home as a long term plan to promote a stable and thriving financial livelihood, you need a company that will be with you in the long term. You need an insurance provider with the capital and fiscal solvency to pay out claims given an unforeseen loss or damage to the property without hesitation.  If you want to see how an insurance provider like Allstate stacks up against itself and the competition financially, look no further than Moody’s.

Moody’s currently ranks Allstate with an Aa3 rating, one of the highest, with minimal risk as far as investments are concerned. The 3 suggests they are also capable of repaying debt obligations in the short-term whereas the double-A depicts them being fiscally solvent with a positive outlook in the future years to come.

Standard & Poor’s

Standard & Poor’s (S&P) is the second of the top three credit ranking agencies, and although we are not getting to it first, S&P proves to be no slouch either when it comes to analyzing, reviewing, and presenting a clear understanding of the global financial market. S&P provides financial guidance in 28 countries with an over 150-year history of providing financial intelligence reports.  These reports include but are not limited to credit ratings and research reports of financial institutions. The video below gives a brief overview of why a credit rating from S&P matters.

The company is divided into three factions, but the faction we are interested in is the rating department. Whereas A.M. Best favored the insurance industry and Moody’s operates on a global scale, S&P is more focused on providing an indexed outlook of the American stock market. They are the end-all when evaluating and determining an accurate review based on any company’s stock.

They have a particular rating section devoted to the current and future outlook of insurance providers. S&P has given Allstate an A- rating; S&P generally takes a more nuanced look into the business practices and considers all the factors. The slightly lower grading evinces that the insurance provider is a good investment but susceptible to changes due to issues such as weather, which are out of their control.

NAIC Complaint Index

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) is a national non-profit organization whose main responsibility is to protect the interests of insurance consumers. They measure and rate insurance providers with the priority of holding each company to the highest of standards. They operate primarily as a watchdog organization with the consumer’s best interest at heart.

Allstate Home Insurance NAIC Complaint Index 2018

The graph above displays Allstate’s complaint rating as compared to the national average in the insurance industry for 2018. The insurance provider is the second overall in the nation, so its no wonder they field more volume in the number of complaints; And their response time and rating, although not the best, is still commendable especially given the size of the insurance provider. Allstate is still measuring well below the national average which is set at one. This scoring shows that they may receive a high number of complaints, but they generally respond quickly and appropriately in resolving those high volumes of complaints issued.

Fitch Ratings

Fitch Ratings (Fitch) rounds out the top three credit ranking agencies and is a leading provider of credit ratings, commentary, and research. They are definitely on par with both Moody’s and S&P in their dedication to providing even-handed assessments of the financial stability and credit ranking of any given corporation.  They maintain that their process is thorough, independently conductive, and always objectively given.

Fitch’s rating system takes into consideration what kind of debt a company holds and how sensitive it is to systemic changes like interest rates. The system operates on letter grades that code signify financial ranking on a global scale.

Fitch rates Allstate with an A- which asses it more in line with S&P’s ranking. It is still viewed as a minimal risk investment, and any hesitation generally has to do with the nature (or weather hazards) of the home insurance industry.

Fitch appears to be cautious in awarding it the highest marks, but this rating, in combination with the other credit agencies, depicts Allstate as a company that still has room for growth while its financial interests remain stable. There is potential for advancement in financial solvency opportunity which makes Allstate not just a safe bet for investing in a home insurance policy today but in the years to come as well.

J.D. Power

J.D. Power has become an American institution for financial reports and quality reviews of corporations and their products promoting the advocacy of consumer intelligence. Founded in 1968 by James David Power III, J.D. Power is not another legacy credit ranking institution and does not place in the top three, but they have become a respected source for information on company performance and product review.

They have primarily made their name in the auto industry, but have gradually taken the same practices to company interests even including home insurance.

In almost every category, Allstate ranks 3/5 in J.D. Power’s review for home insurance. Not the best but for a company their size, number two home insurance provider in the nation, an average score is a win in our book. This also suggests that they may have room for improvement; a slight increase could elevate service from average to great.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Allstate History

Like most insurance providers, Allstate began its storied career with the selling of auto insurance policies in the early 1900s. Unlike those other providers, Allstate was initially developed as a mail-order auto insurance service that eventually morphed into the more person-to-person agent service known today.

The mail-order service was the brainchild of Sears, Roebuck & Co.’s President and Board Chairman Robert E. Wood who after taking inspiration from the success of the Sears catalog realized an opportunity in combining the two businesses. So on April 17, 1931, Allstate opened its doors with the opportunity to purchase auto insurance policies, and by May, Allstate had sold its first insurance policy.

Allstate opened its first permanent sales office in a Chicago Sears store around 1934, and as the company gradually shifted to a more personal agent-driven approach, offices quickly sprang up eventually being opened in a vast majority of Sears department stores throughout the 30s.

The more prominent slogan that Allstate has come to be known by, “You’re In Good Hands With Allstate”, was first thought up by one of Allstate’s own general sales manager, a Mr. Davis W. Ellis. In the company’s first national print campaign, two hands holding a car illustrate the line.

Allstate has made significant strides in custom tailoring insurance policy to meet individual policyholders’ needs since their inception. Their auto insurance policies were some of the first to consider drivers’ needs, ages, and mileage when drafting rates and policies, and soon enough, the entire industry followed in suit. the 1947 introduction of the Illustrator Policy, which simplified the language of policies and added pictures to enhance customers’ understanding of their coverage, facilitated growth.

Allstate would go on to expand outside of the auto industry sphere including the likes of fire insurance, homeowners, and life insurance in the 1950s. The company did so well in the first 30 years at meeting the needs of American Consumers that Allstate decided to even expand globally by selling insurance to Canadians. Allstate Insurance Company of Canada was incorporated in 1964. The only limitations Allstate seemed to place on itself was bringing the business closer focus by selling insurance only by the 1970s.

The 70s also brought on the introduction of two new policies that would greatly benefit both Americans and Canadian citizens. Allstate saw the need and implemented what we know today as the Basic Homeowners Policy and the Healthy American Plan (life insurance).]

In 1991, Sears, Roebuck and Co., offering 20 percent of Allstate’s stock, went public before becoming completely independent of Sears in 1995. At the time, the stock offering was the largest public stock offering in the nation’s history, and today, Allstate has become the nation’s largest publicly held personal property and casualty insurance company.

The 1990s brought with it change;  Allstate diversified its potential to offer great rated insurance policies by utilizing exclusive and independent agents, creating a network of call centers, and expanding their online presence as in their most recent acquisition of competitor Esurance. Allstate continues to be relevant after 80 years as an insurance provider competing in and occasionally creating markets that did not even exist at their onset.

After Allstate became independent of Sears, Allstate has continued to grow and prosper and is now the second-largest provider of property and casualty insurance in the nation servicing approximately 16 million households. The nation agrees that they are in good hands when it comes to Allstate, especially in providing the necessary insurance to promote the safety and security we all desire.

Allstate Market Share

In any industry, market share figures for a single year are informative about a company’s degree of success, but it is the consecutive yearly figures that you should concern yourself with in terms of financial stability. The term itself is relatively self-explanatory; it is the percentage of sales earned (shares) by a company in a particular industry (market) over a specified period.

According to Investopedia, calculating the market share involves dividing company sales by total industry sales over the same period. As mentioned previously, it is the comparisons between companies through multiple years that provides a clear picture of that company’s overall projected performance.  So how does Allstate’s market share affect you as the policyholder? Think of your policy as an investment not only in protecting your home but also an investment in the success of Allstate. You both operate hand-in-hand and benefits for the overall company extend down to the policyholders level as well.

Company2016 - % Market Share2016 - Premiums Written2017 - % Market Share2017- Premiums Written2018 - % Market Share2018 - Premiums Written
Allstate8.64%7,903,530,0008.44%7,957,403,0008.36%8,262,445,000
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Allstate’s market share has seen a continuous loss in the past three years but a minimal percentage. Gains continue to be made in the premiums written, so this shows that business has not grown stagnant. They remain steady and income is coming in so bankruptcy or a drastic fall from the number two position seems unlikely.

Businesses as old as Allstate go through cyclical periods of losses and gains, and these minimal dips are not anything to be concerned about for the immediate future.

Allstate’s Position for the Future

Allstate seems poised to continue to grow steadily in the immediate and far-reaching future. The income that Allstate continues to bring in through premiums written is impressive seeing initial steady growth and a nice jump between 2017-2018. Their loss ratio, amount of claims being paid out in comparison to premiums coming in, remains in a safe range.

This all suggests that Allstate remains a financially stable company and will continue to prosper in the years to come. The only concern we see at this moment is the potential to over-extend oneself as Allstate continues to expand from insurance policies to even the financial sector; but currently, all of this expansion seems like the healthy growth of a profitable company that services its customers well.

Allstate’s Online Presence

Allstate was in early on the ground floor of the internet age having begun creating an online presence in 1996. They have adapted easily to online business having previously provided insurance through mail order; it seems like every trend is cyclical right about now. Online insurance offerings seem to be a similar trade-in style as the mail-order they once provided, and although this is a focus, Allstate continues to offer and push a more personable approach with agent offerings. Just as they transitioned in the past, they have integrated new tech even understanding the need pivoting to adapt and even acquiring rival all-online insurance providers like Esurance.

Aesthetically, the site appears a little crowded although the message projected is straight forward enough and the navigation is generally intuitive. When selecting options it does seem like you hop between too many pages to gather the necessary information. The front page does provide all their main offerings for insurance including home and immediately which is direct, and if you allow them permission to use your location, the site immediately presents local agent options complete with pictures, location, and contact information.

The site has an additional learning center that offers insurance advice on top of general tips for home repair as well as being generally informative about the company and its history. On the top navigation bar, Allstate also offers the option for submitting an online claim for those anxious folks who have difficulty in one-on-one interactions.

Allstate’s Commercials

As has been the trend in recent years since the, an absurdist comedy angle to gain viewers’ attention in hopes they will remember when it comes time to find a provider of their own. In the commercial below, a comedic actor personifies potential mayhem and destruction that can happen to anyone with humorous results.

 

To show they are with the times and constantly adapting their business model to the needs of the consumer, they also have commercials that  bring to mind the current trend of homeowners renting out their homes through the likes of Airbnb.

All things considered, Allstate’s commercials provide depth to their coverage option, unique and genuinely funny while also offering ideas on coverage options you may not have considered in the past. Their coverage is surprisingly inclusive and affords options for many if not every possible consumer need.

Allstate in the Community

As early as the 1950s, Allstate has understood the value of helping the community involving themselves in the lives of their policy holders through their Allstate Foundation. The Allstate Foundation is fully funded by donations from Allstate. It invests both nationally and in the local communities where we live and work. The current website even provides a nice feature displaying an interactive map that shows how Allstate is helping out in your local community.

Allstate touts a contribution of $42.2 million as their current figures for community donations in 2018. While the majority of this donated $42 million in community contributions is provided by the Allstate Foundation, additional funds have been provided to fund other corporate volunteer oriented work wich includes the hometown giving program, the Helping Hands staff volunteer initiative, the Allstate Officer Nonprofit Board Program, plus the Renewal Project and the Better Arguments Project.

All donated money is obviously given in the effort to prove that Allstate supports in communities in addition to providing the necessary insurance. Some of the recent highlights include $6.4 million raised by the 2018 Allstate Giving Campaign which matches employee donations dollar for dollar.

Allstate displays some impressive figures in community volunteerism and benefit; however, the message occasional comes across as slightly insincere or at least not as much of a priority as their top competitor, State Farm. The message received seems to be that they are a publicly traded business first and any donated contributions, although many, seem like an afterthought. This may seem like a negative swipe at Allstate but frankly in our opinion, we find comfort Allstate’s business in the front and volunteer party in the back approach.

Allstate’s Employees

A company is only as good as the employees who work there. We believe good management that treats employees with fairness offering equal opportunity and fare pay trickles down from the employer to employee and eventually the customer.A workforce is only as good as they are treated, and your policy, no matter how affordable or all inclusive the coverage, is worthless if you cannot get a claim serviced appropriately through customer service agents.

On another note, if there are holes in the customer service department, there is probably mismanagement from the top down, and your policy may not be as good as you think it is. Trouble in one area generally spells out even more trouble across the board.

Age of Employees & Tenure

According to Payscale, Allstate has a larger percentage of early career employees as well as experienced tenured positions. Always nice to have an experienced driver behind the wheel of your home insurance policy.

Allstate Home Insurance Graph for Employee Tenure from Payscale

The data obviously depicts that their industry is more adept at providing long term job opportunities. It also shows the Allstate knows the importance of your home investment only letting experienced individuals handle your policy and filed claims. The median age is 35 years old for employees with those fresh faces holding down those jobs for about 2.9 years of tenure. The fresh outlook with young careers offers initially some nice go-getter attitude and the later year experienced staff measures out for confidence group. Generally, nice averages all around.

Employee Experience

Overall, Allstate scores well in this category. Payscale reports slightly above average results for employee experience.

Allstate Employee Satisfaction Results from PayscaleThey even match up with their number one competitor showing you will not get any better service with State Farm; although not on policies written, Allstate can match its competitors in customer service and employee satisfaction.

Awards and Accolades

Allstate is not without their fair share of awards. The more recent recognitions they have received include placement in 2019s Top Ten Military Friendly Companies, 2018-19s Top Companies for Executive Women from the National Association for Female Executives, 2018s Top 50 Companies for Diversity from DiversityInc, 2018s One of the World’s Most Ethical Companies from the Ethisphere Institute, and 2018s Best Companies for Multicultural Women from Working Mother. 

These are just a handful of Allstate’s proud moments spotlighting their industry leading standards that extend to more than the insurance industry including also how they operate as well. Their message continues to promote core values of honesty, caring and integrity.

Before we take you any further into Allstate’s rates and coverage options, why don’t you start this section off with an actual estimate by using our free online quote engine. You will have a better perspective with an estimated cost in front you while reading about all of Allstate’s coverage options. It is simple, just type in your zip code, and we will take care of the rest.

Allstate Cheap Home Insurance Rates

Eventually what it will all come down to is money. The best home insurance policy does you no good if your can not afford to cover it financially. Dollars and cents, dollar dollar bills y’all. We know you want an affordable home insurance policy with the lowest rates; but, you definitely do not want the discount version of coverage coming from your provider.

Allstate seems to hit that just right, Goldilocks sweet spot; as a leading provider of home insurance, number two in the nation, they are large enough to offer affordable rates across the board. On top of that, their size helps policyholders further save on their insurance rates by offering multiple discounts through bundling a variety of insurance options. If your looking for home insurance, chances are you might need auto insurance as well. Allstate not only has you covered on both counts but will offer you premium discounts for multiple policies across various lines of insurance.

Allstate’s size benefits consumers as it is small enough to offer person-to-person agent experience where you feel heard and not lost in the shuffle but large enough to make those claims when unexpected property loss and damage occur. They have the fiscal stability to still be there after all the bills are paid and the rebuilding is finished. It is safe to say that even in a catastrophe, Allstate will keep you in good hands.

Allstate Availability

Allstate homeowners insurance is available in all 50 states and the District of Columbia.

Allstate Compared to the Top 10 Market Share

Allstate is more than competitive in its field as an insurance provider. Currently ranked second in the nation with massive potential for growth. Their expansion into multiple markets including the financial district affords them a wide birth to become a much larger insurance provider than most smaller companies. And then as a bonus for policyholders with multiple lines of insurance, you get discount bundles and payment options all under one roof.

RankCompanyDirect Premiums Written ($)% Market ShareLoss Ratio
1State Farm18,177,46218.50%61.87%
2Allstate8,262,4458.36%65.55%
3Liberty Mutual6,655,4526.74%52.60%
4USAA6,170,5586.24%79.77%
5Farmers Insurance Group5,795,0445.86%78.80%
6Travelers3,766,2773.81%69.34%
7American Family Insurance3,276,2803.32%63.74%
8Nationwide3,184,6273.22%77.83%
9Chubb Ltd Group2,832,0822.87%91.87%
10Erie Insurance Group1,675,9761.70%66.03%
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Allstate has a clear lead in premiums written over the majority of the top ten, State Farm not being considered. And although they are a ways off, to be it politely, from State Farm, so is every competitor in the nation. They more than match up with their true contenders with only Liberty posing a remote if none at all threat to their positioning. Growth is the key factor to consider here, and Allstate shows no signs of slowing down.

Allstate Sample Rates

In order to give you a clearer perspective on the rates Allstate offers, we used the California Department of Insurance’s comparison tool that offers by estimated rates for cities and counties dependent on the desired amount of coverage. Selecting at random, we surveyed Pasadena, California to see some actual price-tags on rates from Allstate as well as how they pair up with the top ten leading competitors. The table below shows how Allstate pairs up to its competitors for home insurance coverage ranging from $200-500,000.

Average Home Insurance Rates of the Top 10 Home Insurance Companies by Dwelling Coverage – Pasadena, Los Angeles County, CA
Companies$200,000$350,000$500,000
Travelers$408$585$795
Allstate$421$734$1,047
State Farm$427$690$972
Nationwide$439$668$961
USAA$448$811$1,154
Liberty Mutual (as Liberty Ins Corp)$656$866$1,076
Farmers$899$1,386$1,869
Chubb Ltd$965$1,564$2,031
American FamilyN/AN/AN/A
Get Your Rates Quote Now

*CA rates based on home age of 1-3 years old, $1,000 deductible

This is by no means an exact figure, rates vary frequently by location, but Allstate clearly is a top competitor when it comes to affordable rates. In each category, Allstate offers some of the lowest rates across the board no matter the coverage cost. This shows that even as the premiums rise, Allstate can afford to keep their rates competitive and even below the average in most instances when compared to some of their biggest competitors.

When you choose Allstate as your home insurance provider, you know you will get a fair and reasonable rate. The chart does show some added padding in dollar amounts as the coverage reaches the $500 thousand range, but frankly, this is reassuring in their continued ability to be able to payout claims of this size. Those insurance companies who drop their rates significantly as premiums go up should be cause for concern. The good hands of Allstate prove to be offering affordable rates with discounts whenever possible and a degree of trust that they know what their doing if the rate increases slightly.

Coverage Offered

Allstate has a variety of insurance lines to pick from with responsibly priced rates and coverage that will be there when you need them. For homeowners insurance, Allstate provides the standard dwelling coverage as well as a litany of extras with the possibility of gaining discounts based on bundling with other lines of insurance options i.e. auto and home plus boat.

Allstate’s Policy Types

Allstate has policy holders covered no matter the living situation offering up homeowner, renters, condo, mobile home, and landlord insurance. They offer so many policies for home coverage you may just end up bundling within the same department line of home insurance.

Homeowners

Allstate offers policyholders a standard homeowner’s insurance with the actual physical structure being covered. Additional options include the belongings inside your home, liability coverage, coverage if a third party injures themselves on your property, and guest medical covering the potential injured third party’s medical bills.

Condo

Allstate provides coverage for your unit and the belongings inside the unit for damage or loss. All of this, though, has to covered under the listed perils which include fire, theft,  accidental water damage from your plumbing, and vandalism.

Renters

Allstate offers surprisingly affordable renters insurance that covers the cost of your belongings within a rental property.

As mentioned in the video, the renters insurance will cover liability, personal property, and additional living expenses that pay for hotel stays if your rental unit is uninhabitable. It does not protect the physical structure. Make sure to check your own rental insurance plan to see what exactly is covered and what is not.

Mobile Home

As technology advances so has the modern convenience of building a home. Manufactured or mobile homes are increasingly becoming a popular option considering the lower price-tag and surprising sustainability of these new models. Allstate’s mobile home policy generally covers the same multiple perils as a standard homeowners policy, which includes offering coverage for the home, liability, and personal property.

Rental Property

Rental property or landlord insurance is provided by Allstate to cover the physical dwelling against damage or loss while renting it out to a third party. Both flood insurance and personal umbrella insurance (in case of lawsuits) are extra but possibly more important given your landlord status.

Additional Policies

Motor-home coverage is an additional policy from Allstate that lands somewhere between auto and home. The insurance leans closer to auto insurance, but it is important to make sure you are covered for liability and damages other than those caused on the road.

Allstate’s Standard Homeowner Policy

The standard type of homeowners insurance that Allstate offers includes coverage for the actual physical structure of your home, your personal property, liability protection, as well as guest medical.

The first two cover the home and the contents of your home. Whereas, the liability and guest medical almost go hand-in-hand addressing issues caused by an injury on your property. This type of coverage is necessary so you do not lose your home financially speaking over someone else’s accident.

The video above details a variety of coverage options that Allstate offers for homeowners. The purpose of the video is to better inform homeowners of their coverage options, possible claims, and what exactly their policy may or may not cover. It provides a level of trust and strength in character for the good hands of Allstate.

If there is something not covered in the standard homeowner policy that you deem worthy of protecting, there are also optional coverages that you can add to an already purchased policy. Things like garden or shed insurance as well as high priced items that are stored in the house are just some of the examples for optional coverage.

On a final note, Allstate also offers personal umbrella insurance policy that covers liability for truly expensive lawsuits that exceed the standard cap. The need for this is rare, but it is nice to have the option if you feel like being especially cautious. As far as flood insurance, an Allstate agent can help you purchase one or you can on your own as this policy is only offered by the National Flood Insurance Program.

Allstate’s Bundling Options

One thing Allstate does not have a problem with is the variety of insurance lines. Seriously, almost like the flavors of the week with Allstate. As an insurance provider with multiple lines of insurance, they do tend to reward policyholders with discounts if they purchase multiple lines of insurance from Allstate. The most common saver being the bundling of auto and home which can save up to 25 percent. And that’s a 25 percent we all know can be well spent elsewhere for business or pleasure.

The other potential bundle benefit included in an Allstate package coverage is convenience and time saving; with almost every type of insurance, Allstate can provide multiple policies, many you probably already have, that you will pay at one convenient location.

Probably the option that provides the most in savings is the combining of home, life, and auto insurance under one package deal. You get 10 percent off alone with combining home and life and up 25 percent by combining home and auto. Just imagine the kind of savings with the trifecta. All of these policies are essential coverage’s as you get older so why not save and purchase them all from Allstate.

Allstate’s Discounts

Allstate offers a variety of homeowner discounts for both new and old policyholders. Even just for switching. The chart below lists just some of the discounts Allstate offers to each of the policyholders.

DiscountPercentage Off (up to)Details/Requirements
EZ Pay Plan5%Set up automatic withdrawal of premium payments
eSmart10%Sign up for online policy management
Full Pay10%Pay full term premium up front
Early Signing Discount10%Sign policy documents at least seven days before effective date
Responsible Payer5%No cancellation notices for non-payment in past year
Auto and Home10% off auto
25% off home
Have both auto and home in force with Allstate
55 and Retired10%Homeowners over age 55 and who are retired
Claim Free25%Homeowners save when they switch to Allstate without a recent home insurance claim
Welcome & Loyalty10%Save on your home insurance premium just for switching to Allstate and continue to save each month as long as you're a customer
Get Your Rates Quote Now

As you can see from the table above, Allstate provides a multitude of discounts. Some of those discounts are even offered for just being an Allstate home policyholder. That is 10 percent right there for switching over, and that discount continues month to month throughout your time as a valued customer at Allstate.

Security Discounts

The security discounts that Allstate offers are they typical fare which include installing/having theft or fire protection devices, a smoke-free homes, storm shutters, and hail-resistant roofs. These are just a few of the examples where Allstate rewards policyholders for being responsible homeowners. They provide incentives to further protect your home investment.

Bundling Discounts

Allstate offers a variety of bundling options but what is best for homeowners is the package deal with auto and life. The auto and home bundle already offers up to 25 percent off rates and that is before the addition of life.

Other Discounts

Allstate is all about discounts, even adding a few options after the more traditional bundling. Some of these untraditional discounts that may apply to you are the 10 percent early signing discount, the 10 percent loyalty discount, the new home buyer discount, and the 55 and retired discount. Do not fret if none of these categories match your homeowning situation because Allstate’s rates are already some of the lowest in the insurance industry. Also, we are pretty sure Allstate will find some way to give you a discount.

Allstate’s Programs

Allstate has its version of a learning center with articles conveniently laid out on each line of insurance’s web-page. The site-specific insurance articles actually provide some useful tips typically helpful for first time home buyers but may still offer tips or tidbits of information to veteran homeowners.

Allstate’s tools include a homeowner vs renter calculator and an inclusive web service focused on planning your move. The site and feature is called the Moving Center and includes initial topics as buttons to further explore. The initial navigation buttons include house hunting, packing up, moving day, and settling in.

Allstate offers some informative features that really seem geared to helping the inexperienced and uninformed make better decisions when it comes to owning a home and purchasing insurance. The rest of the page following the links from the navigation buttons includes articles covering topics such as what an escrow insurance account is and what additional living expense coverage is as well as a homeowners insurance quiz.

Allstate does provide those trademark good hands in their informative easy to navigate website but at times it almost seems like too much information, and there are sometimes too many web-page redirects. You will definitely get the feeling that this is a large company.

The only potential worry that could arise from surveying Allstate’s site is about getting lost in the shuffle of such a large company. These worries are quickly alleviated with the online quote option which is quick and easy with responsive navigation. There is an informal questionnaire that gathers appropriate, home-related information, however, it never really feels like your filling out just another form. So well done on that angle.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Canceling Your Allstate Policy

Before entering a serious contract you should definitely gather an exit strategy just in case you do not like the fit of your insurance provider.

Cancellation Fee

Allstate allows you to cancel your homeowners policy any time with no cost cancellation fees.

Is there a refund?

You will get a pro-rated refund for the unused portion of your premium. The only phone call cancellation can be frustrating, but at least there will not be any hidden fees for canceling.

How to Cancel

You will find that canceling your policy is not as easy as signing up for one. In order to cancel your Allstate insurance policy, you must call your agent. And even then, the agent may ask you to fill out a written request for the cancellation of your policy.

When canceling your policy, you will need to have your policy number, social security number, and the date you would like the cancellation to take effect. The good news is your cancelation can take place on the same day.

When can I cancel?

Allstate allows you to cancel your homeowners policy any time; and unlike some providers, Allstate will even refund a pro-rated amount even if you cancel halfway through your month of coverage.

How to Make a Claim

The unexpected happens and it will happen to you and your home. You pay your monthly insurance rate, and you rightly expect your insurance provider to step up immediately when that unexpected does happen to facilitate a claims process that is both easy and hassle-free.

Luckily, Allstate makes the process just that easy and hassle-free; Allstate offers multiple options for making a claim, each just as effective as the last.

Ease of Making a Claim

Allstate makes claim to having the largest team of claims agents in the country, so the process should be no headache. And if the number of claims agents is anything like the number of filing options, then you are truly in good hands in the unfortunate case of property loss or damage.

You can file a claim online, through the app, over the phone with your agent, and in person with the very same agent. There is also the 1-800-7828 number you can call to file your claim in case your personal agent is unavailable.

Premiums Written

Why should you be concerned with the number of premiums your insurance provider has written? Within a single year, the data is somewhat irrelevant; however, following the numbers across a three year period offers an insiders look into how Allstate is operating as a company financially speaking. You can gather a relatively accurate projection of potential growth which will give you an idea if the insurance provider is worth your investment. Can not file a claim if your insurance provider ends up bankrupt.

Company2016 - % Market Share2016 - Premiums Written2017 - % Market Share2017- Premiums Written2018 - % Market Share2018 - Premiums Written
Allstate8.64%7,903,530,0008.44%7,957,403,0008.36%8,262,445,000
Get Your Rates Quote Now

The table above shows steady growth each year with a general increase in the total number of premiums gained from year to year. 2016 to 2017 shows modest gains, but the 2018 numbers spike upwards reflecting the increasing acquisition of new business from policyholders.

Not only is Allstate’s a stable company with statistics suggesting they are fiscally solvent, but they are also growing each year, This all suggests that Allstate is operating at the top of its game. Policyholders are happy and claims are being processed to the tune of striking up new business. The more they gain in premiums also keeps their loss ratio in check.

Loss Ratio

What is a loss ratio and how does it relate to the number of premiums written. The loss ratio is a comparison of how much the insurance provider takes in with premiums written in contrast to the number of claims they are paying out. Basically, the amount of money coming in versus the amount of money going out.

A loss ratio under 40% is probably too low, and a loss ratio over 75% is too high. If a company’s loss ratio is too low, it suggests a company is not paying out claims as it should and simply pocketing the majority of the premiums. When a company’s loss ratio is too high, the insurance provider is running the risk of bankruptcy.

Too low and the company may be a cheat; too high and the company is mismanaged running itself into the ground. There is wiggle room on either end especially in the high loss ratio category; an insurance provider is clearly not running the risk of bankruptcy if these spikes do not occur in consecutive years. They more accurately reflect an oncoming rate increase which is not positive for the policyholder.

Company2016 - Premiums Written2016 Loss Ratio2017- Premiums Written2017 Loss Ratio2018 - Premiums Written2018 Loss Ratio
State Farm17,613,109,00054.25%17,556,871,00080.93%18,177,462,00061.87%
Allstate7,903,530,00049.98%7,957,403,00055.60%8,262,445,00065.55%
Get Your Rates Quote Now

In comparison to the nation’s top contender, Allstate has handled itself in a more stable fashion than the number one provider Allstate; the figures suggest a higher degree of fiscal solvency. There is a bit of a jump particularly between 2017 and 2018, but there was also a significant jump in premiums written (collected income) to counterbalance the increase in claims paid out.

The numbers for Allstate remain well within the safe range each year projecting success in the years to come,

How to Get a Quote Online

Getting a quote online through Allstate has never been easier. By visiting their website at www.allstate.com, there are several options for finding an online quote depending on the line of insurance you are interested in. The front page has an easy enough layout with each insurance option represented by an icon. After selecting home, you are redirected to the home insurance main page where you will type in your zip code. After your location is determined, it is on the next page where you are actually ready to begin.

Step One: Enter Your ZIP Code

With your ZIP code entered, Allstate conveniently offers you their bundling options at the start which includes auto, motorcycle, off-road, renters, and term life.

Allstate Home Insurance Getting Started Online Quote Visual

We went ahead with the single homeowners insurance option, but it is a nice feature to conveniently have these bundling options upfront instead of afterward with the best guesstimate of your savings.

Step Two: Provide Basic Information About Yourself

A basic questionnaire follows where you provide your name, marital status, age, and sex.

Allstate Home Insurance Online Quote Step One Visual

Step Two: Enter Your Home Address

After supplying Allstate with this general personal information, you will be redirected to the next page and prompted to give more information about the location of your home. Allstate Home Insurance Online Quote Step Two

Step Three: Enter Contact Information

Your contact information is the next step.

Allstate Home Insurance Online Quote Step Three

You provide both your email and phone number with express permission for Allstate to contact you about this quote as well as an option to cancel this permission whenever you choose.

Step Four: Provide Property Details

Now it is time to provide some actual details about the home you want to insure. The more inclusive you are with your information the more accurate the quote will be in the end.

Allstate Home Insurance Online Quote Step FourThe following pages ask you to provide necessary information about your property such as the year your home was built, the type of structure (one, two, or three story), the square footage, the purchase date, the roofing condition, and the foundation and basement condition. Additional questions to prepare for include whether you have a pool or attached structure, fireplaces, burglar or fire alarms, and a sprinkler system.

This whole section covers basic home info; the headers for the sections are exterior, interior, and safety.

Step Five: Provide Household Details

The next section involves informing about your household or the individuals residing in your home.

Allstate Home Insurance Online Quote Step Five

This section mainly is attempting to find out how much of a liability you may pose as a policyholder. Questions include how many in your household, if you smoke, if you have filed claims recently, automobiles, do you currently have insurance, and start date of your new insurance.

Step Six: Calculate Discounts

Savings, the best part is truly saved for last. Allstate calculates all the potential discounts you can take advantage of from the information you provided.

Allstate Home Insurance Online Quote Step Six

You have the option to include these discounts in your online quote offer or leave them out.

Step Seven: Get Your Quote

Not much of a step here as after the discount page, you are redirected to a detailed report of potential insurance options and their quoted cost.

Allstate Home Insurance Online Quote Step Seven

The laundry list provided of coverage options along with quoted prices is impressive; the information ranges from standard dwelling coverage, personal property, other structures, additional expenses, to cyclones and weather patterns. The three big sections include property coverage, coverage for you and others, optional coverages including sewage issues, roof maintenance, and green enhancements.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Design of Website/App

The website provides a wealth of information with an intuitive navigation system that occasional gets bogged down with too much information. That being said, it runs smoothly, offers a very detailed and informative online quoting system, as well as a variety of articles to increase policyholder knowledge and awareness of potential insurance issues.

There seems to be a significant amount of clutter, and the whole site could use a whole less is more straightforward to it. The site is truly made for the modern youth consumer visually as it is constantly multitasking your options; the eye tends to darts too much back and forth causing the appearance of slight confusion.

The information is there but the layout could be much cleaner and the message more direct with fewer options.

The Allstate Mobile app is primarily focused on automotive, but the inclusion of bill pay, policy search, and ID cards are a convenient addition to Allstate’s already option heavy features. Homeowners can now pay their monthly bills with the touch of a button on their phone.

Allstate Home Insurance Mobile app

Allstate has put a significant amount of time and effort into their online presence; all that money and effort does show on their mobile app, but it remains, as mentioned previously, auto-centric in its functions. Homeowners can take advantage of easy bill claims, photo-ready immediate claims filing, and digital ID cards though.

The app is a huge hit with policyholders and their on-the-go lifestyles.

Allstate Home Insurance Mobile App Review

As you can see from the review graph above, the mobile app is one of the highest-rated insurance apps out there on the google play store. A nice average of positive reviews with feedback and actual response for fixing issues in the comments section. There are some issues with retrieving documents, but these petty gripes come from a desire to speed up even the immediacy of phone access to your policy. The Allstate mobile app is now available for android and iOS operating systems.

Pros and Cons

ProsCons
Allstate offers a variety of insurance line options including home ensuring that they can be the one stop shop for all your insurance needsAllstate operates so many different lines of insurance that the departments can become confusing sparking fears of possibly getting information lost in the shuffle
Allstate has a significant online presence offering a detailed online quote and bill pay option through their website and appAn Allstate policy is not so easy to cancel forcing customers to call their agents and even then in some cases provide written notice of cancellation
Allstate offers several discounts on bundling options the biggest being a 25% discount on Home & AutoThe multitude of discounts often feel like a carrot held out front on a stick prompting questions like why not offer more of these values uprfront
Get Your Rates Quote Now

The Bottom Line

Allstate is the number two insurance provider in the nation and makes an effort to give back to the community.

Allstate is a publicly-traded insurance provider that relies on increased capital for profits and this is in no way a negative trait. And how have they increased the capital fueling their financial success? By constantly pivoting and changing to the needs of the market and their consumers. From the early days, Allstate has been open to change altering service from mail delivery to a more agent-driven business model and now by increasing their online presence. All of this success is caused by meeting the needs of their policyholders.

Their array of insurance options makes them a one-stop-shop for all lines of insurance. Homeowners are easily covered with affordable rates that are slightly below competitors. They’re also more than willing to provide discounts for the consumer especially when bundling

Allstate’s straight forward business approach is admirable which is represented by their above-average credit rating, and for individuals with the need for multiple policies, they sure are a great candidate.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

FAQ

#1 – How can I pay my bill?

There are multiple options for paying your monthly bill. Probably the most convenient is online or through the mobile app both of which take direct payments. Otherwise, you can pay by phone calling 1-800-901-1732 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Or, you could opt for the more traditional, old school method of mailing a check to the address on your policy statement.

#2 – Do You Handle Property Damage from Natural Disasters Differently?

The short answer is yes. Allstate covers natural disasters as listed by multiple perils in your policy. The long answer; Generally what occurs is first the natural disaster would be classified as a catastrophe. Then, a crew of claims adjusters known as the National Catastrophe Team will have boots on the ground within days to assist and provide detailed instructions about filing claims.

In most cases, policyholders would be in contact with Allstate’s Mobile Claims Center. The phone number to call in these situations is 1.800.54.STORM (1.800.547.8676).

#3 – Will My Premium Increase If I File a Claim?

This all depends on the circumstances involved in the claim and the homeowner’s actual coverage as detailed in their policy, Every claim is unique, and it is best to review your options with your local Allstate agent. You would lose any discounts, such as the Allstate Claim Free Discount, and your premium could increase. Once again, your agent or a claims agent can look at your particular situation and detail your options.

Now that you have all the facts, go ahead check out our free online quote search engine. Just enter your ZIP code below, and we will do the rest in providing you a tangible starting point to protecting your home investment with an insurance policy that meets your needs.

About Eric Stauffer

Author: Eric StaufferI am a former insurance agent and banker turned consumer advocate. My priority is to help educate individuals and families about the different types of insurance they need, and assist them in finding the best place to get it.

Leave a Rating

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *