UPDATED: Nov 30, 2018
We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We partner with top insurance providers. This doesn't influence our content. Our opinions are our own.
Compare Insurance Quotes
About Presbyterian Healthcare
Presbyterian Healthcare traces its roots to Southwest Presbyterian Sanatorium, a small tuberculosis sanatorium created in 1908 in Albuquerque, New Mexico. As the tuberculosis crisis waned, the sanatorium changed its focus, and in 1950 changed the name to The Presbyterian Hospital Center.
The following decades saw expansion across the state, with new facilities added and the addition of Presbyterian Health Plan to provide health insurance to members. The health plan branch offers individual and family plans, group health, and Medicare Advantage plans.
Health plans offer access to all of Presbyterian’s facilities and providers as well as an extended network of providers across the state.
Presbyterian Health Plans
Presbyterian offers PPO health plans at all levels, as well as Medicare Advantage options for those who qualify.
Individual & Family Plans
All of Presbyterian’s individual plans, at all levels, include vision coverage, fitness center memberships, and access to video consultations with a doctor (at no charge on most plans). They offer plans from Catastrophic to Platinum.
The Catastrophic plan, like all plans of this type, has a fairly high deductible that applies to most services. The deductible is $7,350 individual and $14,700 family, which is also the out of pocket limit. Three primary care visits are offered at no charge each year, after which the deductible applies. All visits are covered in full after the deductible.
There are three Bronze plans. The Bronze 3 plan is much like the catastrophic, with the same deductibles and all services except preventative care subject to that deductible before services are covered in full.
The Bronze 2 plan has a lower deductible at $6,550 individual (doubled for families). Again, all services are covered in full after the deductible is met.
The Bronze 1 plan differs in that it has a copay of $20 for primary care visits, which are not subject to the deductible. The deductible, which is the same as the Catastrophic and Bronze 3 plans, applies to most other services, including prescriptions, which are covered in full when the deductible is met.
Four Silver level plans are offered, with differing deductibles and copays/coinsurance amounts.
Silver 1 has a low deductible at $2,800 individual, doubled for family. Services, aside from preventative, are covered with a 20% coinsurance after the deductible is met.
Silver 2 has the lowest of all the silver level deductibles, at $2,500 individual, doubled for family. There is a $30 copay for primary care visits, and Tier 1 prescriptions have a $0 copay as well – neither is subject to the deductible.
Silver 3 is also a copay plan, with a higher $4,500 deductible for individuals, double for family. The primary care copay is $35, and again Tier 1 drugs are $0; neither is subject to the deductible.
Finally, Silver 4 has the highest deductible at $5,000 individual, $10,000 family. It has the lowest primary care copay, at $20, and matches the preceding 3 silver plans with a $0 Tier 1 copay. Again, these services are not subject to the deductible.
There are two Gold level plans available. Gold 1 is a low deductible plan with a $500 individual deductible that is doubled for families. It has a $25 copay for primary care office visits, and again the $0 copay for Tier 1 drugs.
Gold 2 is essentially the same in terms of coverage, but has a higher deductible at $3,750 individual in return for a lower monthly cost.
Finally, there is one Platinum plan available. It has the lowest deductibles at $100 individual and $200 family, and the lowest primary care copay at $5 per visit. Prescription coverage again has a $0 copay for primary care.
Medicare Advantage Plans
Presbyterian Senior Care is the company’s Medicare Advantage program. Both HMO and PPO plan options are available, and there are no deductibles with any of the plans.
There are three HMO plans. Plan 1 is the $0 added premium option, but does not include prescription drug coverage. Primary care visits are $5, and specialist visits are $50 under this plan.
Plans 2 and 3 both include prescription drug coverage. Plan 2 has copays of $5 for primary care and $50 for specialist care, while Plan 3 lowers the specialist care copay to $40. Both plans cover Tier 1 drugs with a $4 copay, increasing from there. There is a deductible for Tiers 3 and above of $400 on Plan 2 and $250 on Plan 3.
There are two PPO plan options. Both plans have the same copays of $5 for primary care and $50 for specialist visits. Plan 1 does not include prescription drugs, but Plan 2 does; this is the main difference between the two. Plan 2 has a $375 prescription deductible that applies to all Tiers, with copays the same as the HMO plans after the deductible is met.
We ran a sample quote for a 30-year old, single, non-tobacco user living in the same zip code as the company headquarters.
The lowest rate is, not surprisingly, the Catastrophic plan, which isn’t available after age 30. This plan is $178 per month. Bronze 3 is the next most affordable, jumping to $251 per month.
The most expensive plan offered is the Platinum plan, at $519 per month.
Since this company serves only one state, we are unable to compare the rates on a national level; they do, however, seem on par with similar plans elsewhere. In fact, for PPO plans, the rates are fairly reasonable.
Medicare rates start at the $0 premium plan (on top of the regular Medicare premium). At $163 per month, the PPO Plan 2 option is the most expensive. Overall, the Medicare rates appear reasonable for the coverage.
Presbyterian Health Plans, like all health insurers, handle claims internally. Out-of-network coverage may require a little more time and is more likely to encounter issues than in-network.
The company’s website offers little in the way of information regarding claims, though this is common for a health insurer. The main customer service line should be able to direct questions.
Ratings and Consumer Reviews
The Better Buesiness Bureau (BBB) page for this company is a general one for all of the Presbyterian Healthcare branches, including the health plan. The current rating is an A+, and there are 12 complaints on file in the past three years. Four of those were closed in the past 12 months.
We were unable to find much in terms of direct reviews of the health plans offered by Presbyterian Health. The National Committee for Quality Assurance gives Presbyterian Health Plan an overall 3.5 rating, which is moderate. In underlying categories, we see a lot of 2.5 and 3.0 ratings particularly in consumer satisfaction, although there is a 4.0 for consumer’s overall rating of the health plan.
The Bottom Line
Presbyterian Health Plan offers a good selection of health plans at rates that are in line with many similar companies, in fact fairly reasonable for PPO plans. We found nothing of concern in ratings, and few reviews, leaving a good impression of their reputation. They appear to be a solid choice for health insurance in New Mexico.
For a list of companies that we recommend, visit our Best Insurance Companies page.