Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
Select Page

Homesite Insurance Review & Complaints: Life, Auto & Home Insurance

Homesite Insurance Company offers term life, auto insurance, and Homesite home insurance to families, individuals, and businesses. Homesite insurance ratings from A.M. Best and the Better Business Bureau are A and A+, respectively. Our Homesite Insurance review finds that a Homesite insurance quote for 30-year-old male returns individual Homesite insurance rates ranging from $14.90/mo to $22.60/mo.

FREE Insurance Comparison

Compare quotes from the top insurance companies and save!

Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Eric Stauffer is a former insurance agent and banker turned consumer advocate. His priority is to help educate individuals and families about the different types of insurance they need, and assist them in finding the best...

Full Bio →

Written by

UPDATED: Sep 23, 2020

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We partner with top insurance providers. This doesn't influence our content. Our opinions are our own.

Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by insurance experts.

Homesite Insurance
Financial Strength

Compare Insurance Quotes

Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Homesite Insurance started out offering solely home insurance and renters insurance policies, aiming to keep rates down through an entirely online direct buy experience.

The time-consuming process of finding the right insurance policy that meets all your needs can be often be intimidating and confusing. Many may also find an in-person policy purchase to be even more of a nerve-wracking experience that only adds to the pressures of purchasing an insurance policy.

You would think with the wealth of information at your fingertips with internet, the choice of which insurance company should be easier. But how do you decide with so many options out there? And how can you be certain that you picked the right insurance company that will meet your needs when purchasing online?

Homesite Insurance heard these complaints and stepped up to the plate to make the online insurance buying process easier.

And if too many options when it comes to insurance is still your problem, that is where we come in. Our detailed guide will help you narrow your search to find an insurance company that specializes in offering certain types of insurance policies that meet your needs. If you are looking for the best in online purchasing of home and renters insurance, then you need look no further than Homesite Insurance.

Who is Homesite Insurance owned by? Is Homesite Insurance part of Progressive or Geico?

They are now owned by American Family Insurance and offer a range of products mainly through that affiliation.

Whether it be for your car, home, or life, safeguarding your investment is an important step in protecting you and your family today and in the many years to come. Our detailed guide of Homesite Insurance will provide you with the information you need to make the decision process easier when it comes to purchasing the right insurance policy that meets your needs.

If you are curious to see what a Homesite Insurance policy would cost in your area, then check out our free online quote option. Just type in your ZIP code, and we will guide you through the rest of the process. And before you know it, you will have a detailed quote to help you make an informed decision on which insurance policy is right for you. It is that simple.

Homesite Insurance Ratings and Consumer Reviews

Any bank would do their homework in researching your financial history before investing and offering you a loan, and it should be no different with your insurance company. You need to make sure that the insurance company you invest in is financially secure.

We have provided both financial rating as well as product review ratings below in the headers that follow.

A.M. Best

Is Homesite insurance reputable?

The best way to vet an insurance agency is looking at their credit ranking from the only credit agency that focuses on insurance companies, A.M. Best. A.M. Best currently ranks Homesite Insurance with an A rating which means the insurance company is financially sound for today and in the near future.

What does this mean for you the policyholder? This means that Homesite Insurance is a good candidate financially speaking to safeguard your investments. Homesite Insurance is more than capable of backing up any insurance policy, whether it be home, renters, life, or car, that you would purchase from them.

J.D. Power

J.D. Power measures customer reviews and rates products. They have made but also extend to industries such as insurance.

In the homeowners category of insurance, J.D. Power gives an overall rating of two out of five in product review but also awards them 760 out of 1,000 points in overall consumer satisfaction.

The circle ratings may be on the low side showing some need for improvement in the Homesite complaint department, but the more accurate point rating system shows that well over half of consumers are pleased with the product and Homesite Insurance customer service.

Better Business Bureau

Homesite has an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (BBB). They are not accredited and have a total of 108 complaints closed in the past three years, with 22 of those in the past 12 months.

There have been 316 Homesite Insurance reviews posted on Consumer Affairs, giving the company a rating of just over 1 star overall. The majority of the reviews are negative. Most of these involve a very difficult claims experience.

Yelp has 12 reviews and a 1-star rating overall. The volume here is not too high, but the complaints are much the same.

A lot of the complaints appear to come from customers that purchased Homesite policies through Progressive or Geico; many of these customers were surprised to learn that they did not actually have a policy with the company they purchased through, an issue that cannot be blamed on Homesite.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

About Homesite Insurance

Homesite Insurance was founded in 1997 in Boston, MA, and has since expanded across the country, offering coverage in most states. They are a home insurance company, as the name implies and for much of their history offered solely home and renters policies.

In 2014, Homesite became a part of American Family Insurance, and their website now advertises that they also offer term life insurance, auto insurance, and commercial insurance. The auto and life insurance products are actually underwritten by American Family, while Homesite continues to write their home insurance policies. Commercial insurance also appears to be directly underwritten by Homesite.

Homesite Insurance Group has several member companies, and policies may be underwritten by any of those companies depending on where you live.

Homesite products are sold directly online and not through agents – with the exception of those that are through American Family, as an agent may be involved in those. They also partner with major car insurance companies to provide homeowner’s insurance in order to create a bundle for their customers – Progressive and Geico are among them.

Homesite Insurance Products

Homesite’s website offers only basic information on their products, with an outline of standard and optional coverage for each option. Since they do not underwrite auto or life insurance, we will not go over those products in detail – check out our review of American Family Insurance for information on their auto and life products.

Home Insurance

Homesite’s base insurance policy for a single-family home includes coverage for the structure and for personal possessions, as well as loss of use and medical payments to others. Unusually, the policy does not appear to come with liability insurance as a standard coverage.

The options listed are extended coverage on the house itself, coverage for special valuables, identity theft, and personal injury protection. While it is not named that way, the personal injury protection appears to be what would be called personal liability at most insurance companies. There is no explanation for this.

The Condo policy, on the other hand, does include personal liability as a standard coverage. In every other way, it is much the same as the home insurance policy, with the exception of the structure coverage that is not needed for a condo. Personal injury protection is again offered as an option.

Like the Condo policy, the Renter’s policy also includes personal liability coverage. It also adds mold protection as a standard coverage, which is pretty unusual for this type of policy.

Homesite also offers flood insurance as a separate add-on policy.

Commercial Insurance

Similar to the personal side of things, Homesite does not provide much of a description of their commercial products.

They write General Liability policies, Business Owner’s Package policies, and Worker’s Compensation as well.

Life and Auto

These two products are underwritten by American Family Insurance. The auto page takes you directly to that company’s website for a quote, but the life insurance appears to be sold and quoted by Homesite in spite of being an American Family product.

The life insurance policies offered are both term life, one being a standard term policy and the other an annual renewable policy. Limited information is offered on these products.

Homesite Insurance Rates

Since auto insurance with this company is actually written by American Family, we recommend visiting our review of that company in order to get rate and policy information.

We ran a quick quote for term life insurance, using the sample of a 30-year-old male non-smoker living in California. The coverage amounts offered in the quote ranged from $50,000 up to $250,000, with 10, 20, and 30-year terms available.

A $100,000 10-year level term policy was quoted at $14.90 a month. At 30 years, the same policy was quoted at $22.60 a month. Those rates are reasonable, but not the least expensive we have seen for similar coverage.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Homesite Insurance Claims

Claims can be filed online for almost any of the products offered by Homesite. There is also a toll-free number available. It is not stated whether or not this claims line is open 24/7, but it appears to be given that business hours are not listed. The Homesite contact page also lists a separate claims number at 1-866-621-4823.

Both email and physical mailing are also options for contacting Homesite about insurance claims. The email address is while the physical corporate address is listed below:

Homesite Insurance
One Federal Street
Boston, MA 02110

The online claims system is only accessible by logging into the customer area of the account, which most customers should be able to access easily given they likely purchased their insurance policy that way.

There is a brief FAQ section on claims that cover the basics of the process on the company website. Homesite will assign an adjuster and then send an appraiser out to assess the damage, after which coverage and benefits will be determined.

Clicking on the Homesite Insurance login button on the website will let customers manage their policies online. If you need further assistance, the Homesite Insurance phone number for customer service is 1-800-466-3748.

Life insurance is the one product for which claims information is not listed in the main section. Life claims are handled through American Family – as are auto claims – but that information is only found in the fine print.

The Bottom Line

Homesite likely gets a lot of its business through partnerships with other companies, and they may be a good choice if you are looking to bundle your Geico or Progressive policy. The general lack of details on their products makes it hard to determine what kind of value they offer, and it is, therefore, difficult to form a solid opinion of the company.

Have we piqued your interest in purchasing an insurance policy from Homesite Insurance online?

Either way, you can get a better idea of how much such a policy will cost you by using our free online quote option. All you have to do is type in your ZIPcode, and we will take care of the rest. We will provide you with a detailed run down of a Homesite Insurance policy of your choosing. The online process just got a whole lot easier and more informed.

For a list of companies that we recommend, visit our Best Insurance Companies page.

Compare Insurance Quotes

Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Review Information

Review Date
Homesite Home Insurance
Author Rating

About Eric Stauffer

Author: Eric StaufferI am a former insurance agent and banker turned consumer advocate. My priority is to help educate individuals and families about the different types of insurance they need, and assist them in finding the best place to get it.


  1. Homesite homeowners insurance gets an A+ from us here in Peoria, Arizona!

    They took care of our claim and Candelario did an excellent job!

    We can’t say enough about the excellent service and help they provided!

    We recommend them highly!

  2. Omg. I have NEVER had a bad experience with Homesite.

    Jake was top of the line, professional, compassionate, and paid the max my policy would allow on everything.

    Debris removal, landscaping, hotels, etc. My house was a total loss and I was shocked at how awesome this company was.

  3. Homesite insurance lies and takes advantage of single mothers.

    Stay away from this insurance company!

    I filed a claim with my homesite insurance to fix the roof of my home.

    In eight years I’ve never filed a claim, but I’ve noticed leaking lately.

    When I first got my insurance, they said it was 1 percent deductible.

    When I called in to discuss my insurance, they said that it was 2 percent deductible.

    I called Homesite, my insurance company through Geico, and they changed it to 1 percent because they realized they had made a mistake.

    Then, I filed a claim. Now, Homesite is saying that they have to charge me 2 percent deductible because I had called before and later changed it to 1 percent.

    They lied to me from the start, and because I never filed a claim before, I never knew that they had lied to me.

    If you have Homesite Insurance, drop them immediately and change your insurance company.

    There’s a good reason why they have a one-star rating!

  4. Homesite Insurance Company raised my rate from 453.00 to 765.00 (a 65% increase) for next year July 1, 2019-July 1, 2020.

    There was no apparent reason for this increase other than greed.

    I have had no claims with them and have had them for several years.

    Prior to this past outrageous increase, they had been raising me an average of 50.00 per year.

    This increase was by far the most extreme.

    When I phoned them as to why they could not give me any logical explanation.

    I warn others to stay away from this greedy company. Michael B.

    • We also had this same issue with them!

      We were paying 1315 a year, they increased us to 1416 the next year and then 9097 the next!

      We have filed with BBB because and increase of 546% is complete robbery!!

  5. Homesite is worse than anything I have read. I have already had two different adjusters who worked my hail and water damage claim from June of 2018. First, when I decided to change my homeowners to Progressive I was assured that I would receive first class service for a lot less than the homeowners policy I had with another premium company. In the past, if I had a claim a check was cut before the adjuster left my home. Moving forward until I had a claim I had no clue about this low life company Homesite. The run around started immediately when I filed my wind/hail and water damage claim. I saw a person on my roof taking pictures of my home and everything else. When I asked what was going on I was told he was inspecting my home for pre-existing damage. He told me everything was great and left. I invited him inside to look if needed and he said no. After my claim was filed a field adjuster scheduled an inspection. He didn’t look at a third of my damage and told me my roof was in great shape. Moving on I had a painter doing some exterior work. He came down from the second story and told me to come up and look at my torn up roof. I had a total knee replacement so I was afraid but did make it to look. I am retired after almost fifty years building huge 10-50 million dollar construction projects all over the U.S. My roof was destroyed by large hail from the storm in June of 2018. Beat all up? I have several thousand dollars of interior damage as well. I contacted a very well known Roofing Contractor to look at my roof. The Estimator also brought a hail report that matched my date of loss claim. I have been called a liar and totally given the runaround. The adjuster I have right now must be from the Mafia. He is a crook and the end of the road hoping I will just go away. My claim exceeds $ 40000.00 and not one dime has been paid. I paid for some inspections and protective work that I submitted invoices for reimbursement as requested. As I expected Homesite lied too me again. I submitted the invoices by email, fax and US Mail. All were lost and please send again. I am working with the Attorney Generals Office to hopefully send someone to prison for theft of my hard earned money. I am a senior citizen and will not be screwed without a fight. Here is the bottom line a field adjuster will come out and examine the damage then the games begin. Now a desk adjuster takes over and you start all over. By design, they will try to make you the idiot for asking any questions. Trust me, record all conversations and then convert to a text format. Bam you will clearly see it’s a scam. Pay them and let them collect and never pay back anything at all. Hire crooks mainly ex-bill collectors and you beg for help. You could send them your arm and they are so cold-hearted it would be a huge laugh. I hired a private investigator to track down my current desk adjuster. I want to know everything about this mean jerk. Don’t use Homesite or as I say Home theft Bullies. Shame on you jerks. Progressive should be ashamed. Now I know how Progressive can pay for all of their adds. All profit and screw the homeowner. I also had an auto claim. Someone hit my new car parked at the airport when I traveled out of town. I was treated like it was my fault. A small two thousand dollar claim took a month to get a check and I was charged with an accident? Someone hit my parked car legally parked at the airport. Both Homesite and Progressive are low life carpetbaggers. Texas

  6. This article must be partially paid by Homesite insurance. It recommended this company and gave it more stars than they deserve. Homesite is not a good insurance company because of their underhanded practices.

    • Hi Marcus,

      Thank you for taking the time to leave your feedback. As of the time of this writing, we have no relationship with Homesite, and never have in the past. They had no interaction or influence as it relates to this review.

      Eric Stauffer

      • It seems like your with them because so far I’ve seen nothing but one star rating of overall complaints, siding with a company like this makes yours look bad

        • Hi Kevin,

          As I previously stated, as of this writing we have no relationship with Homesite (nor have we).

          Eric Stauffer

  7. Homesite Insurance is the worst company to deal with! I got a quote on our vacation home. Someone came out, took pictures and then raised the premium about $200. That was ok; until I received all my money back (via a credit to a credit card). I was now being told that the roof had to be replaced. We told the gentleman that came to the vacation home that all materials to replace the roof were in the garage, which we showed him and he took pictures of that, too. The roof was replaced within the timeframe that they asked for. Pictures and receipts were scanned and sent to them. Homesite claimed that the pictures were not good enough and that the receipts were unreadable. I scanned the receipts darker, went back to the house and took another set of pictures. That still was not good enough for them. I offered to overnight the originals of the pictures and the receipts to them. There is no physical address to receive these types of items. It goes to a central clearinghouse that will scan the photos and receipts thereby ending up in the same boat. I suggested that they send the person out who originally did the inspection. Homesite said no, “we only visit a property once. That’s our policy.” Needless to say, I did nothing to try to make this work after that ridiculousness. I wouldn’t let this company insure by doghouse!!!! Can’t tell you how much this company is a rip-off!!!!

  8. I filed a claim against a policyholder after being told specifically that my claim would not affect their premium. We were friends with the policyholder & did not want to compromise their policy. Well, after the insurance company paid me, they canceled the policyholder. WORST COMPANY EVER!!! DO NOT INVEST IN THEM, THEY WILL SCREW YOU OVER!!

  9. We had LaTuna fires on 9/1/2017 which devastated the whole Glendale, Burbank, Sunland and Tujunga areas.
    After 2 months of back and forth, they denied our claim without any regard to our damaged personal property. Please stay AWAY from this company.

    Neighbor’s washing machine exploded April 1, 2016 and flooded my garage and part of my kitchen. Contacted Homesite Insurance, A PROGRESSIVE COMPANY and started a claim for damages. [Redacted] was assigned the claim as my adjuster. His smooth Texas style and accent was supposed to lull me into happiness. He reassured me that his 30 years of experience as an adjuster would make this claim move easily. He told me that I need to get an Angie’s List subscription and find local contractors to deal with repairs and the damage. I went out, found several contractors, took the time off of work, had them come provide estimates, sent these to [Redacted] at HOMESITE INSURANCE, A PROGRESS COMPANY and was told to go ahead and start the repairs. They sent a check for the Service Master crew that arrived to do initial destruction and drying of water damage. Then they sent another check to me. They told that the funds were incorrect so I returned the uncashed checks to HOMESITE INSURANCE , A PROGRESSIVE COMPANY. A bill was received from Service Master and I immediately paid it as it arrived 30 days late and had extra fees attached to it. HOMESITE INSURANCE , A PROGRESSIVE COMPANY did not pay them and expected me to pay out of pocket.
    The contractor that I selected to do the repairs did the work on the damage and when the work was completed, I paid them for their work. During this time, [Redacted], disappeared and was no longer handling my claim. I was then told that [Redacted] was the new adjuster. He reviewed the materials submitted concerning this claim. I had additional damage to claim that was identified after the initial assessment. I was told provide an estimate which was done. I was told go ahead and do the work. After the work was completed, I again paid the contractor.
    [Redacted], adjuster, cut a check to Service Master for their water mitigation work and he also cut me a check for the initial costs. He finally cut a check for personal property that was lost in this claim.
    I submitted a final invoice for the last work that needed to be accomplished and [Redacted], CLAIMS ADJUSTOR FOR HOMESITE INSURANCE, A PROGRESSIVE COMPANY sent me a reply stating that I had been overpaid for this claim and that I owe them $217.17. I explained to her that this work was identified after the original damage was assessed. She did not care that I have already paid $500 dollar deductible and had “DEPRECIATION” withheld from what I am owed. Now I have [Redacted], Recoverable Depreciation Associate, requesting photographs and estimates and information concerning the last work accomplished. There is some subrogation company involved with the claim and even with all of these people here to make my claim as efficient as possible, NO ONE IS REPLYING TO EMAILS, CALLS OR ATTEMPTS AT COMMUNICATION.
    At this point, I have no other recourse other than seeking legal representation and suing HOMESITE INSURANCE, A PROGRESSIVE COMPANY for failure to do what they are supposed to do. I am still almost $2000 out of pocket into this claim and no relief in sight.
    As soon as this gets resolved, I intend to move my 2 cars, motorcycle and house away from PROGRESSIVE INSURANCE AND THEIR ASSOCIATED COMPANIES due to their lousy customer support.
    My advice to anyone considering insurance with the PROGRESSIVE FAMILY OF INSURANCES is to look elsewhere. It is true, you get what you pay for.

    • I had similar issues with them. I never received full payment. I was shorted almost $2000 for repairs, called depreciation. I filed to reclaim my so called depreciation. I sent them all the required paperwork, itemized statement from contractor, receipts and bank statements plus proof I paid the deductible. They had already deducted the $1000 when they sent me a check. How do I prove to them that they took out the deductible. Anyway, I never was paid. 3 months later, some millennium from their office emailed me. I just blew them off. $2000 is not going to ruin me. They need the money worse than I do. Pitiful company.


Leave a Rating

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *