Best Indiana Medicare Supplement Companies & Plans (2024)
Medicare supplement (Medigap) in IN is available from a wide variety of companies, including major health care insurers and smaller insurance companies. Because Indiana Medicare supplement plan options are standardized, you can compare Indiana Medicare supplement rates from multiple companies knowing the coverage is the same.
Free Medicare Insurance Comparison
Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save
Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
Angie Watts
Licensed Real Estate Agent
Angie Watts is a licensed real estate agent with Florida Executive Realty. Specializing in residential properties since 2015, Angie is a real estate writer who published a book educating homeowners on how to make the most money when they sell their homes. Her goal is to educate and empower both home buyers and sellers so they can have a stress-free shopping and/or selling process. She has studi...
Licensed Real Estate Agent
UPDATED: Feb 16, 2024
It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.
Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We are not affiliated with any one insurance provider and cannot guarantee quotes from any single provider.
Our insurance industry partnerships don’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own. To compare quotes from many different insurance companies please enter your ZIP code on this page to use the free quote tool. The more quotes you compare, the more chances to save.
Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by insurance experts.
UPDATED: Feb 16, 2024
It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.
Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We are not affiliated with any one insurance provider and cannot guarantee quotes from any single provider.
Our insurance industry partnerships don’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own. To compare quotes from many different insurance companies please enter your ZIP code on this page to use the free quote tool. The more quotes you compare, the more chances to save.
On This Page
- You can add Medigap coverage to your Indiana original Medicare plan
- There are 77 companies offering Medicare supplement plans in Indiana
- Indiana Medicare supplement plans can’t be added on to a Medicare Advantage plan
Medicare supplement policies in Indiana are available from a wide variety of sources, including major health insurance companies and smaller insurance providers. Also known as Medigap, Medicare supplement fills the gaps in original Medicare to cover things like coinsurance and deductibles.
IN Medicare supplement plan options are standardized, so all companies must provide the same coverage on each policy type. Not every company offers all of the possible Indiana Medicare supplement plans, so consider your options and then find the right company for your needs.
To find the best Medicare supplement rates in IN, enter your ZIP code above. You can compare fast, free Medicare Supplement quotes in Indiana right now.
Standard Medicare Supplement Plans in Indiana
Indiana Medicare supplement plans are standardized, and every company must include the same coverage on the plans they choose to offer. Compare the details of each plan here to see what level of Indiana Medicare supplement coverage is right for you.
Medicare Supplement Plans in Indiana
Plan Name | Monthly Cost | Copays Coinsurance | Deductibles | Plan Benefits |
---|---|---|---|---|
Medigap Plan A | Premiums range from $72-$1,207 depending on your age, sex, health status, and when you buy. | $0 Generally your cost for approved Part B services | $1,484 Hospital (Part A) deductible, $203 Medical (Part B) deductible |
Skilled nursing facility: No
Part A deductible: No Part B deductible: No Part B excess charges: No Foreign travel emergency: No |
Medigap Plan B | Premiums range from $94-$716 depending on your age, sex, health status, and when you buy. | $0 Generally your cost for approved Part B services | $0 Hospital (Part A) deductible, $203 Medical (Part B) deductible |
Skilled nursing facility: No
Part A deductible: Yes Part B deductible: No Part B excess charges: No Foreign travel emergency: No |
Medigap Plan C | Premiums range from $107-$591 depending on your age, sex, health status, and when you buy. | $0 Generally your cost for approved Part B services | $0 Hospital (Part A) deductible, $0 Medical (Part B) deductible |
Skilled nursing facility: Yes
Part A deductible: Yes Part B deductible: Yes Part B excess charges: No Foreign travel emergency: Yes |
Medigap Plan D | Premiums range from $101-$583 depending on your age, sex, health status, and when you buy. | $0 Generally your cost for approved Part B services | $0 Hospital (Part A) deductible, $203 Medical (Part B) deductible |
Skilled nursing facility: Yes
Part A deductible: Yes Part B deductible: No Part B excess charges: No Foreign travel emergency: Yes |
Medigap Plan F | Premiums range from $106-$1,152 depending on your age, sex, health status, and when you buy. | $0 Generally your cost for approved Part B services | $0 Hospital (Part A) deductible, $0 Medical (Part B) deductible |
Skilled nursing facility: Yes
Part A deductible: Yes Part B deductible: Yes Part B excess charges: Yes Foreign travel emergency: Yes |
Medigap Plan F-high deductible | Premiums range from $29-$224 depending on your age, sex, health status, and when you buy. | $0 Generally your cost for approved Part B services after you pay $2,370 deductible | $2,370 total plan deductible. After, you pay: $0 Hospital (Part A) deductible, $0 Medical (Part B) deductible |
Skilled nursing facility: Yes
Part A deductible: Yes Part B deductible: Yes Part B excess charges: Yes Foreign travel emergency: Yes |
Medigap Plan G | Premiums range from $93-$1,036 depending on your age, sex, health status, and when you buy. | $0 Generally your cost for approved Part B services | $0 Hospital (Part A) deductible, $203 Medical (Part B) deductible |
Skilled nursing facility: Yes
Part A deductible: Yes Part B deductible: No Part B excess charges: Yes Foreign travel emergency: Yes |
Medigap Plan G-high deductible | Premiums range from $29-$213 depending on your age, sex, health status, and when you buy. | $0 Generally your cost for approved Part B services after you pay $2,370 deductible | $2,370 total plan deductible. After, you pay: $0 Hospital (Part A) deductible, $203 Medical (Part B) deductible |
Skilled nursing facility: Yes
Part A deductible: Yes Part B deductible: No Part B excess charges: Yes Foreign travel emergency: Yes |
Medigap Plan K | Premiums range from $47-$339 depending on your age, sex, health status, and when you buy. | 10% Generally your cost for approved Part B services up to $6,220. Then, you’ll pay $0 for the rest of the year. | $742 (50% of Part A deductible) Hospital (Part A) deductible, $203 Medical (Part B) deductible |
Skilled nursing facility: Yes
Part A deductible: Yes Part B deductible: No Part B excess charges: No Foreign travel emergency: No |
Medigap Plan L | Premiums range from $61-$696 depending on your age, sex, health status, and when you buy. | 5% Generally your cost for approved Part B services up to $3,110. Then, you’ll pay $0 for the rest of the year. | $371 (25% of Part A deductible) Hospital (Part A) deductible, $203 Medical (Part B) deductible |
Skilled nursing facility: Yes
Part A deductible: Yes Part B deductible: No Part B excess charges: No Foreign travel emergency: No |
Medigap Plan M | Premiums range from $69-$825 depending on your age, sex, health status, and when you buy. | $0 Generally your cost for approved Part B services | $742 (50% of Part A deductible) Hospital (Part A) deductible, $203 Medical (Part B) deductible |
Skilled nursing facility: Yes
Part A deductible: Yes Part B deductible: No Part B excess charges: No Foreign travel emergency: Yes |
Medigap Plan N | Premiums range from $71-$711 depending on your age, sex, health status, and when you buy. | $0 Generally your cost for approved Part B services with some $20 and $50 copays | $0 Hospital (Part A) deductible, $203 Medical (Part B) deductible |
Skilled nursing facility: Yes
Part A deductible: Yes Part B deductible: No Part B excess charges: No Foreign travel emergency: Yes |
Are you looking for free insurance quotes?
Your one-stop online insurance guide. Get free quotes now!
Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
Medicare Supplement Plans by Company in Indiana
You have a lot of choices when it comes to Indiana Medicare supplement companies. Here you’ll find a complete list of companies selling Medigap policies in IN, as well as which plans they offer. Refer to the details of each plan in the section above to help you decide which company has the right Indiana Medicare plans for you.
Medicare Supplement Plans by Company in Indiana
Read more: Best Indiana Medicare Supplement Companies & Plans
Company | Plans |
---|---|
AARP – UnitedHealthcare Insurance Company (Level 1) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan B, Medigap Plan C, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G, Medigap Plan K, Medigap Plan L |
AARP – UnitedHealthcare Insurance Company (Level 1/Household) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan B, Medigap Plan C, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G, Medigap Plan K, Medigap Plan L |
AARP – UnitedHealthcare Insurance Company (Level 2) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan B, Medigap Plan C, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G, Medigap Plan K, Medigap Plan L |
AARP – UnitedHealthcare Insurance Company (Level 2/Household) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan B, Medigap Plan C, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G, Medigap Plan K, Medigap Plan L |
AARP – UnitedHealthcare Insurance Company (Standard) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan B, Medigap Plan C, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G, Medigap Plan K, Medigap Plan L |
AARP – UnitedHealthcare Insurance Company (Standard/Household) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan B, Medigap Plan C, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G, Medigap Plan K, Medigap Plan L |
Accendo Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Aetna Health and Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan B, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G |
American Benefit Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
American Financial Security Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield – Indiana | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Assured Life Association | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Bankers Fidelity Assurance Company (Preferred) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G |
Bankers Fidelity Assurance Company (Standard) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G |
Capitol Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Central States Health and Life Co. of Omaha | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan D, Medigap Plan F |
Cigna National Health Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Cigna National Health Insurance Company (Standard II w/ 15% HHD) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Cigna National Health Insurance Company (Standard II w/ 6% HHD) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Cigna National Health Insurance Company (Standard II) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Cigna National Health Insurance Company (Standard III w/ 15% HHD) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Cigna National Health Insurance Company (Standard III w/ 6% HHD) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Cigna National Health Insurance Company (Standard III) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Cigna National Health Insurance Company (w/ 15% HHD) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Cigna National Health Insurance Company (w/ 6% HHD) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Colonial Penn Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan B, Medigap Plan D, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G, Medigap Plan K, Medigap Plan L, Medigap Plan M |
Colonial Penn Life Insurance Company (Substandard) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan B, Medigap Plan D, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G, Medigap Plan K, Medigap Plan L, Medigap Plan M |
Combined Insurance Company of America | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Elips Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Erie Family Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Everence Association Inc. | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan C, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G, Medigap Plan L |
Federal Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
GPM Health and Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Garden State Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G, Medigap Plan M |
Globe Life and Accident Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Great Southern Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G |
Great Southern Life Insurance Company (Class 1) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G |
Guarantee Trust Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Heartland National Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan D, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G, Medigap Plan M |
Humana (Humana Benefit Plan of Illinois, Inc.) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G |
Humana Achieve (CompBenefits Insurance Company) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Humana Healthy Living (Humana Insurance Company) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan K |
Humana Healthy Living (Humana Insurance Company) (Household) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan K |
Humana Value (HumanaDental Insurance Company) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G |
Humana Value (HumanaDental Insurance Company) (Household) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G |
Independence American Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Manhattan Life Assurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Medico Corp Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G |
Members Health Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan B, Medigap Plan C, Medigap Plan D, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G, Medigap Plan M |
Nassau Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
National Guardian Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
National Health Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G |
National Health Insurance Company (Household) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G |
New Era Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan C, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G, Medigap Plan M |
Oxford Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Pan-American Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Pekin Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Physicians Life Insurance Company (Issue Age) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G |
Prosperity Life Group (Preferred) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Prosperity Life Group (Standard) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Puritan Life Insurance Company of America | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Resource Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Sentinel Security Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Shenandoah Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan C, Medigap Plan D, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Transamerica Life Insurance Company (Direct) | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan B, Medigap Plan C, Medigap Plan D, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G, Medigap Plan K, Medigap Plan L, Medigap Plan M |
USAA Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Union Security Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
United American Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan B, Medigap Plan C, Medigap Plan D, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G, Medigap Plan K, Medigap Plan L |
United Commercial Travelers of America | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan B, Medigap Plan C, Medigap Plan D, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
United Insurance Company of America | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan D, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
United States Fire Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan B, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G, Medigap Plan K, Medigap Plan L |
United World Life Insurance Company | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G |
Wisconsin Physicians Service Insurance Corporation | Medigap Plan A, Medigap Plan C, Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G, Medigap Plan K, Medigap Plan L |
Physicians Life Insurance Company (Attained Age) | Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan F-high deductible, Medigap Plan G |
Physicians Life Insurance Company (Innovative/Attained Age) | Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Physicians Life Insurance Company (Innovative/Issue Age) | Medigap Plan F, Medigap Plan G |
Compare Indiana Medicare Supplement Rates
Ready to compare Indiana Medicare supplement plans for your needs? Enter your ZIP code to get fast, free quotes for IN Medicare supplement today.
Find Medicare Plans in Your Area for Comprehensive Coverage
Explore Medicare plans available in Bloomington, Indiana; Henry County, Indiana; Richmond, Indiana; Central, Indiana; Miami County, Indiana; Valparaiso, Indiana; Crawfordsville, Indiana; New Castle, Indiana; Warsaw, Indiana; Dearborn County, Indiana; Ossian, Indiana; and West Lafayette, Indiana. Find the coverage that suits your needs.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes a Medicare supplement company the “best” in Indiana?
The “best” Medicare supplement company in Indiana can vary depending on individual needs and preferences. However, some factors to consider when evaluating companies include their financial stability, customer service reputation, plan options, pricing, and coverage benefits.
Can I switch Medicare supplement companies in Indiana?
Yes, you can switch Medicare supplement companies in Indiana. However, it’s important to understand the guidelines and enrollment periods specific to Medigap plans. Depending on your circumstances, you may be subject to medical underwriting or have guaranteed issue rights, which allow you to switch plans without medical underwriting.
Are there any specific Indiana-based Medicare supplement companies?
While there may not be any Medicare supplement companies based exclusively in Indiana, there are numerous companies that operate in the state and offer Medigap plans to Indiana residents. These companies may have a regional or national presence.
What factors should I consider when choosing a Medicare supplement plan in Indiana?
When selecting a Medicare supplement plan in Indiana, consider the following factors:
- Coverage needs: Assess the areas where Original Medicare falls short and select a plan that fills those gaps.
- Cost: Compare premium rates and out-of-pocket expenses for each plan.
- Provider network: Check if your preferred healthcare providers accept the plan.
- Plan stability: Evaluate the company’s reputation for premium stability and rate increases.
- Additional benefits: Some plans offer extra benefits like vision, dental, or fitness programs.
How do I enroll in a Medicare supplement plan in Indiana?
To enroll in a Medicare supplement plan in Indiana:
- You must be enrolled in Medicare Part A and Part B.
- Research and compare Medigap plans offered by different companies.
- Contact the company of your choice to apply for the desired plan.
- Ensure you enroll during the appropriate enrollment period and follow the application process provided by the company.
Are Medicare supplement plans in Indiana standardized?
Yes, Medicare supplement plans in Indiana, as in other states, are standardized. This means that the coverage benefits for each plan are the same, regardless of the insurance company offering the plan.
Are you looking for free insurance quotes?
Your one-stop online insurance guide. Get free quotes now!
Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
Angie Watts
Licensed Real Estate Agent
Angie Watts is a licensed real estate agent with Florida Executive Realty. Specializing in residential properties since 2015, Angie is a real estate writer who published a book educating homeowners on how to make the most money when they sell their homes. Her goal is to educate and empower both home buyers and sellers so they can have a stress-free shopping and/or selling process. She has studi...
Licensed Real Estate Agent
Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by insurance experts.