Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
Select Page

Austin Mutual Insurance Company Review

Austin Mutual Insurance Company offers coverage in 19 states with plans for Austin Mutual auto insurance, Austin Mutual homeowner's insurance, and commercial insurance. Our Austin Mutual Insurance review finds no online Austin Mutual insurance rating from the Better Business Bureau. Austin Mutual insurance claims can be filed online or over the phone.

FREE Insurance Comparison

Compare quotes from the top insurance companies and save!

Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Eric Stauffer is a former insurance agent and banker turned consumer advocate. His priority is to help educate individuals and families about the different types of insurance they need, and assist them in finding the best...

Full Bio →

Written by

UPDATED: Aug 7, 2020

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We partner with top insurance providers. This doesn't influence our content. Our opinions are our own.

Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by insurance experts.

Austin Mutual Insurance Company
Financial Strength

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Minnesota-based Austin Mutual Insurance Company has been in business for more than 100 years, offering products ranging from personal car insurance to farm insurance. They serve 19 states as a part of Main Street Insurance Group.

Our Austin Mutual car insurance review will cover its auto insurance policies as well as other products. Find out how to get Austin Mutual car insurance quotes and how Austin Mutual car insurance rates look compared to other companies.

If you’re ready to compare car insurance quotes from multiple companies right now, just enter your ZIP code, then read our Austin Mutual auto insurance review below.

About Austin Mutual

Originally founded as State Farmers Mutual Hail Association in 1896, a move of the company headquarters from Mankato, MN to Austin, MN in 1909 inspired the name change to Austin Mutual Insurance Company. The company no longer operates in the city of Austin, having moved to Minneapolis in 1930 and finally the Austin Mutual Insurance Maple Grove, MN head office, where it remains today. Austin Mutual Insurance payments are processed at this location.

In 2012, Austin Mutual became a part of Main Street Insurance Group, and they no longer operate an independent website. This makes it difficult to determine which of the products offered by the group of insurance companies under the Main Street name are actually offered by Austin Mutual. Nowhere on the website does it indicate which policies are issued by which of the eight companies in the group, simply describing Austin Mutual as writing “commercial and personal insurance”.

This makes reviewing the company’s products somewhat difficult, but we will provide an overview of the products Austin Mutual was writing at the time of our last review when the company still operated an independent website.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Austin Mutual Products

Prior to the merger of the websites, Austin Mutual offered personal auto, home insurance, commercial policies, and agribusiness coverage.

Auto Insurance

The Main Street website offers a basic overview of the auto policies offered by their underwriting companies, one of which is Austin Mutual. In addition to all of the required state minimum coverages, the policy offers all of the common options and some of the trendy choices as well.

Listed are new vehicle replacement, accident forgiveness, diminishing deductible, and OEM parts replacement; these are often add-on enhancements from most insurance companies, but the website is not clear as to whether or not that is the case here. They do appear to be add-on coverage options that likely have an additional premium.

Also featured is the Auto Elite program, which has three levels of enhanced coverage. All three levels include transportation expenses, personal property, roadside assistance, and accidental airbag deployment. The other enhanced coverages include things like loan/lease gap coverage, trip interruption, and diminishing deductible – but what the three levels are and which of these is included is not explained.

Home Insurance

Again, home insurance policy information is combined on one page on the Main Street website, with no clear indication of how coverage might differ depending on the underwriting company.

Home insurance policies provide all of the basics of coverage including structures, personal property, and liability, with several add-on enhancements offered. Like the auto program, there is a Home Elite package enhancement offered at three levels. All three levels include replacement cost coverage, but the benefits differ from there.

Additional endorsements include home systems coverage, cyber protection, and identity theft.

Commercial Insurance

The Main Street website lists a wide variety of commercial products. At the time of our last review, Austin Mutual offered business package policies, business auto, and business umbrella policies for small to medium companies. It seems likely that they continue to underwrite this type of coverage under the Main Street banner, but again the combined website makes it hard to tell.


Austin Mutual has long been active in the agribusiness market, and we so no reason to believe this would have changed since our last review. Main Street’s website states that they offer a solid range of commercial agribusiness policies, and although they do not name any of their companies specifically, Austin Mutual has a long history in that industry.

Austin Mutual Insurance Rates

Rates are not available for Austin Mutual, and all quotes are done by local independent agents. When requesting a quote from a Main Street agent, it is likely the underwriting company could be any of the group’s brands unless a quote from Austin Mutual is requested specifically.

Without rates, it is very difficult to compare Austin Mutual to its competitors, but in general, we expect small companies like this one to come in a little higher on premiums and make up for the added cost with customer service and personal attention.

Austin Mutual Insurance Claims

Any Main Street America customer can report claims either online or over the phone, and that includes Austin Mutual customers. Claims are handled by one central claims reporting line for the entire group, which is available 24/7. Claims can also be reported through your agent.

The website does not specify whether Main Street handles claims processing for its member companies or whether they all handle their own claims independently, but reporting does appear to be centralized.

Main Street also has a group-wide preferred repair network for auto repair claims, called Shop of Choice. There is little-detailed information either about this program or about the claims process in general.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Austin Mutual Insurance Ratings and Consumer Reviews

Austin Mutual does not have any rating on its own Better Business Bureau (BBB) page, which states complaints against the business are handled by another BBB. That is likely the BBB page for Main Street America Group, which shows an A+ rating. The group has eight complaints on file and 12 reviews. This is quite a low complaint volume, especially if that covers all eight underlying companies.

Austin Mutual does have its own Yelp page, where there are only two reviews, both of which are one-star. One complaint is in regards to a claim, and the other to a non-renewal by the company.

The eight Google reviews are mixed, with an overall 2.3-star rating. Rate hikes and customer service problems are the main complaints in these reviews.

Overall, there is a pretty low complaint volume for this company and no red flags within the reviews.

The Bottom Line: Austin Mutual Insurance

Austin Mutual’s merger of their website with that of Main Street America Group makes it hard to extricate information specific to that company, which in turn makes it hard to get a good picture of what they offer. They are the type of company that relies on agents to bring in new business, which explains the lack of detail on the site. If you prefer to work with an independent agent and like a smaller, regional company, Austin Mutual may be worth exploring with your agent’s assistance.

Ready to compare quotes now that you’ve read our Austin Mutual auto insurance review? Enter your ZIP code right here.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Review Date
Austin Mutual Insurance Company
Author Rating

About Eric Stauffer

Author: Eric StaufferI am a former insurance agent and banker turned consumer advocate. My priority is to help educate individuals and families about the different types of insurance they need, and assist them in finding the best place to get it.


  1. We were customers of Austin Mutual for many years, had great service.

    When rates were hiked by 40% I was unable to get an answer from customer service- who were clueless, I decided it was time to change.

    New auto insurance policy was 1/2 of what Austin Mutual was charging me.

  2. Do not do business with this outfit.

    They run you in circles when you try to get info.

    They lie about who they have contacted and when.

    They also drag out your payments as long as possible by doing extra paperwork that should have done right the first time.

  3. I’ve been with Austin Mutual for several years and have had positive experiences with them: Customer service, rates, and claims when I was deemed at fault. Can’t comment regarding how it is if another driver with different insurance goes through them for a claim since this hasn’t happened with me. They do charge a $3 fee to pay your bill online, however, there are options to avoid this by either paying with check or automatic withdrawal from an account. In addition, a $7 mailing fee exists if you choose to have your bill sent. However, you can avoid this if you pay the bill before it generates (Can call them and they will inform the generation date). Overall, I would recommend Austin Mutual!

  4. I’m thankfully not covered by by them. One of their insured hit my PARKED car and they are still investigating to see if they can cover the accident. [Redacted] in the claims department is your stereotypical insurance agent. Her voicemail says she will return your call in 4 hours; however it took 6 DAYS, 3 phone calls AND the mention of getting a lawyer before she would bother to call me back. I dealt with my insurance and Austin Mutual with this accident. [Redacted] and Austin Mutual are the worst I’ve had to deal with. Good luck to all their policy holders, I hope you do not have to use your insurance.

    • Austin Mutual has great rates and fortunately I have never had to file a claim so I cannot comment on how easy it is to file and deal with a claim. I do know that they have to have the worst customer service department of any insurance company operating in the 21st century. No policies available online. They charge you $3.00, soon to be $4.95 for every payment you make online. My agent has tried to add an additional driver to my policy and in 3 weeks the company has not made the change and just today sent me the dec sheets for my renewal 6 days before the renewal date and no driver has been added and there was no bill included. Must be a bunch of slow moving dinosaurs working there.


Leave a Rating

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *